Apple iPad 2 Preview

Apple today announced the iPad 2, a minor and evolutionary update to its market-leading tablet device. There were no major surprises at all, with virtually all of the feature set, accessories, and applications having been previously divulged by various rumor sites and other sources. But the iPad is important, and this update, while disappointing in its lack of scope, will no doubt usher in another year of market dominance and sales for the company. With Apple, it's not how well you do, it's how well your fans love you.

And Apple's fans love this company.

Here are my initial reactions about the iPad 2, which are based on watching various live blogs during the announcement event. I'll later watch and rewatch official video of the event when it's released by Apple, and will of course review the iPad 2 in the coming weeks.

Steve Jobs. The iPad announcement was hosted by ailing CEO Steve Jobs, which excited the audience for obvious reasons. I'm glad he was able to do it.

Announcements. As always at Apple events, it all began with various announcements about product milestones and put-downs for the supposed competition. Apple has now sold 100 million iPhones. 2010 was "the year of the iPad," with 15 million units shipped. This is more than "every Tablet PC ever sold," Jobs claimed. The iPad has over 90 percent market share, which seems pretty low when you think about it: There are only a tiny number of competitors in the market. 65,000 iPad specific apps are available now.

iPad is not a computer. Apple very specifically claims that the iPad is a post-PC device and NOT a computer. I hope that settles that argument.

iPad 2. There was curiously little news about the iPad, which is a small evolutionary update over the original device. (Or in Jobs' words, "an all-new design.") The new A5 CPU is dual-core and "twice" as fast as the processor in the original. Graphics are "nine times" faster. Power consumption is the same as with the original. Front and rear cameras. Built-in gyroscope. It's one-third thinner than the original, 13.4 mm down to 8.8 mm. ("Thinner than the iPhone 4.") Lighter too. All as expected.

They're going to have black and white versions, and white is shipping on day one. (The white iPhone 4 still hasn't shipped.)

Bad news: AT&T and Verizon are supported from day one (but not in the same hardware. So there are actually 18 (!) different versions of the iPad: Three Wi-Fi, three 3G with AT&T, and three 3G with Verizon, and then each in white as well. Yugh. Battery life, while excellent, is still the same as with first iPad. Worse, so is the price. Apple typically keeps the price the same and bumps up capacities. This time, they kept the price AND the storage capacities the same. That is too bad. So Wi-Fi versions are $499 (16 GB), $599 (32 GB), and $699 (64 GB), and Wi-Fi + 3G versions are $629 (16 GB), $729 (32 GB), and $829 (64 GB), just like before.

The iPad 2 ships next week, March 11, in the US, and March 25 in other markets around the world.

iPad 2 accessories. Apple announced two interesting accessories for the iPad 2. The first is an HDMI out cable/dock that mirrors the iPad 2 display, not just for video and audio, but also for apps. I suppose this means you can play iPad 2 games on an HDTV, basically, which is pretty cool. Supports up to 1080p. Unlike, say, the Apple TV.

The second is a cool new take on a case, where a very thin micro-fiber screen sits on top, held on by magnets. You can fold it over for holding the iPad. It cleans the screen while covering it, which is obviously a necessity. And there are many colors, which is neat.

iOS 4.3. As with the iPad 2, most iOS 4.3 details had previously leaked. Dramatically improved Safari performance. iTunes home sharing. AirPlay improvements (photo sharing with transitions, apps and web sites can share over AirPlay). iPad switch preferences (mute or orientation, fixing a user complaint), personal hot-spot (but for iPhone 4 only).

Apple announced some new iOS 4.3 apps: Photo Booth, FaceTime, iMovie, and Garage Band (all as on the Mac). None of these are particularly interesting to me. (The latter two are paid apps, and will cost $4.99 each. This is reasonable.)

What didn't get announced? While most of the iPad 2 stuff was as expected, Apple said nothing about non-reflective screens, even as an option. This is very, very disappointing as the screen is the current iPad's Achilles Heel.

Recap. A few months ago, I wrote an article called How Apple Can Fix the iPad in 2011. Here's how the company did fulfilling my wish list:

Pricing. Nope.

Form factor. Slightly improved.

Storage. Nope.

Cameras. Yes.

Screen. Nope.

Expansion. 1 for 3: HDMI out as requested but no USB or SD.

Overall reaction. Mixed. The original iPad is good, not great. And the iPad 2 is improved. But is it great? The screen may be a deal-breaker for me, and I am very surprised they did not address this. We'll have to wait and see until I can get my hands on one. I will say this, however. The iPad isn't just the device, of course. It's the device plus the ecosystem. And when you add this all up, the iPad 2 really does stand alone atop the nascent tablet device market. And that will be true for a long, long time.

Discuss this Article 3

yoshipod
on Mar 2, 2011
Why am I not surprised at all by Paul's initial review.


He finds a way to knock a 90%+ market share.

He still thinks its priced too high, despite other tablets that cost more and offer less. He makes no argument why it should cost less or by how much, just that its should be cheaper. Funny that he never called any Windows Phone 7 model too expensive when there are cheaper alternatives around.

Speed increases to processing and graphics of 200% and 900%, along adding two cameras and a gyroscope all while reducing thickness by 33% and weight by 10%, with no loss of battery life are called "minor" and "slightly improved".

He is still confused by all the "models". Is anyone else in the world confused by this? Somehow he is not confused by the number of various Windows Phone 7 devices, yet is apparently overwhelmed by having to choose between how much storage you want, and picking between cell service from one of two carriers of just going wi-fi. Now with a white model, there are actually 18 models to choose from, so his math is even wrong. Oh no, how will consumers figure it all out.

The ipad2 is by no means a game changer, but it is more than a minor update.
pthurrott
on Mar 2, 2011
Thank you for your awful comments.

It is priced too high, yes. So are other tablets.

This is an evolutionary update, sorry.

I am not "confused" by the number of models. I am saying there are too many models. Just as there are too many Windows 7 SKUs. Same kind of complaint, equally applied.

I agree the iPad 2 is no game changer. I guess you're not totally wrongheaded. Just mostly.
yoshipod
on Mar 2, 2011
"It is priced too high, yes. So are other tablets."

Why are they priced to high in your mind? Because you can get a cheap netbook made with low end parts and no touch screen for half the price? They are the same cost as most smart phones without a contract. What is the right price?

"This is an evolutionary update, sorry."

I agree, never said it wasn't. But the updates are certainly not "minor". Are they massive or earth shattering, of course not. But starting out right off the bat calling them minor is not right either. A twofold speed increase is certainly not minor.

"I am not "confused" by the number of models. I am saying there are too many models. Just as there are too many Windows 7 SKUs. Same kind of complaint, equally applied."

You are making this into an issue when its not in an effort to make Apple look bad. No other company in this industry has made such a substantial effort to minimize the number of SKUs and simply their product line like Apple has. In fact, so many other constantly knock Apple for not having enough choices.

Hardware generally offers many more configurations than software as their are real marginal costs to add them. Yes it would be great if Apple only offered the 64GB model and it came with all the hardware for every cell carrier and it cost $299, but that is not realistic.



Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use