Logitech: We Give Up, Google TV is a Train Wreck

OK, they didn't actually say it that way, but sometimes I feel like my job is to cut through the PR niceties and just tell it like it is. And in this case, the truth isn't so far off from what was publicly said. Which is this:

[The Google TV-based Logitech Revue set top box was] "a mistake of implementation of a gigantic nature," Logitech CEO Guerrino De Luca said yesterday. "We have no plans to introduce another box to replace Revue."

De Luca didn't stop there. He said that the Google software that shipped with the box last holiday season at launch was basically a "beta" and that it was all "a big mistake." "We just built a lot because we expected everybody to line up for Christmas and buy these $300 boxes."

This mistake, along with operational miscues in the EMEA region, cost Logitech "well over $100M in operating profits," according to De Luca.

I have a Google TV device, a Sony Internet TV that is lacking in every imaginable way. It's just an absolute waste of time and money.

If you're looking for yet another way to get entertainment content on your HDTV today, there are two big contenders right now: The Apple TV and Roku 2, and Microsoft's Xbox 360 could be a third assuming they get the Internet TV stuff right. We'll see. But as of today, Google TV is indeed a train wreck.

Discuss this Article 4

dukrous
on Nov 11, 2011
Paul, I've had great experiences using my PS3 for putting my media on my TV. With Netflix and Hulu apps (without a need to pay for an Xbox Live Gold account) and Windows Media Sharing, non-DRM media works great.
runesos
on Nov 12, 2011
An interesting question in this regard, is what Microsoft plans to do about the settopbox market. Apple has already answered this with AppleTV, and recently with the iPad and Iphone 4S beeing able to show the image directly on the TV. All three devices are in some way a media station. Exactly how Microsoft will administer it's contracts and agreements with media holders on the xbox 360 platform is something I find interesting to see. The could potentially do a kind of "ipod touch" edition of the xbox 360, where you wouldn't have the ability to play the biggest games, -and this console like thing could be manufactured by many different companies unlike the xbox360. Or they could just take the media-consumption part of the xbox360 and put it on Windows 8 and let Logitech and the like manufacture settopboxes with Windows8. Windows 8 is looking like a more and more powerful platform every time I think of it. It was interesting to hear from the AsiaD conference that both Apple and Google look at the phone and the tablets as the same device, while they consider the desktop something else. Windows 8 is the oposite, considering the desktop/laptop and tablet something different than the phone. Exactly where the xbox360 fits into this is a bit difficult to see at the moment, but at least the expression of the interface on xbox360 is going towards metro-land. There is no set-top-box-like thing with iOS on it, which I find strange. However, out of iOS, Android and Windows 8, the latter is the one that I think has the biggest appeal on a TV screen.
LemonSaucy
on Nov 12, 2011
You .. Anyway, why not just use your cable TV? There's several hundred channels on it .. isn't that enough TV? And if it isn't, um, maybe you need to examine your priorities?
spivonious
on Nov 17, 2011
Yeah, Google TV just never seemed like a viable product to me. I'm perfectly happy with my Windows Media Center HTPC. I really hope that MS is keeping us HTPCers in mind when working on Windows 8.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use