Microsoft Touts IE Win in Performance Study

Microsoft is today touting a web performance study that found the software giant's latest browser, Internet Explorer 9, to be faster than the competition. The study was performed by New Relic, which captured 690,000 page views per minute of real-time performance data that came across an extensive network of sites and users.

"New Relic found that IE9 loaded pages, on average, half a second faster than both Google Chrome and Mozilla Firefox," Microsoft's Ryan Gavin wrote in a post to the Exploring IE Blog. "New Relic's findings mirror the results from web performance experts at Strangeloop, who in January found that IE9 and Firefox were both about 5% faster than Chrome at loading real websites."

The following chart pretty much summarizes the findings, though I'm a bit curious that IE 10 faired so poorly:

fastest_browsers

Two comments about browser performance.

First, in my own admittedly non-scientific tests, I find that all the major browsers--IE, Chrome, and Firefox--"perform" similarly and that in real world use, you won't actually notice that one is faster than the others. What makes browsers more or less efficient is, I think, a better barometer at this time. For example, one of the things I can't stand about Firefox is that it doesn't auto-complete text you type in the address bar like IE and Chrome do. It just makes the browser less usable to me. 

Second, since moving to Microsoft's web-based email services, I've been using IE more and more. In fact, if you examine my Wakoopa profile, you'll find that IE isn't just my most-used browser, it's one of my most-frequently-used apps overall. I like IE, use IE, and think it performs very well. And that's as true of IE 10 on Windows 8 as it is of IE 9 on Windows 7.


Discuss this Article 7

ndberg
on Apr 5, 2012
Did anyone else click the link to the study and notice that the *slowest* browser on Mac OS is faster than the *fastest* browser on Windows? Just sayin'
GoodThings2Life
on Apr 5, 2012
@nate ... So what you're saying is that it's relevant to point out that the Blackberry Mobile Browser is faster too and that ALL if Apple's mobile devices and browsers are dramatically slower than EVERYTHING except Opera Mobile. Honestly, I agree with Paul... the whole study is pointless.
Info Dave
on Apr 5, 2012
Thanks for the heads up Nate. It really is a pretty good write up. I explained there that I thought the Windows numbers were slower because they are sampling slow, POS Windows computers, that Apple doesn't sell. Let's not get ahead of ourselves.
markuslaff
on Apr 6, 2012
The thing I notice about IE9 is how fast pages respond after they have rendered. Scrolling flies, picture galleries are typically very fluid, and things like Google Reader are equally smooth and responsive. My only gripe is that the menu's and interface beyond the tabs kind of have an IE6 stink about them. For now, I stick with Chrome and hope that MS will continue to refresh the desktop interface for IE10.
yoshipod (not verified)
on Apr 6, 2012
I think the best take away from this is that competition spurs improvements. A decade ago when IE ruled all and other browsers did not really even exist or has such small share, there was stagnation. However, once other browsers made substantial improvements, IE was forced to respond. Now IE can help push other browsers to improve. Lets hope this plays out in the mobile world where no single company or product dominates, making each vendor constantly improve their products.
LemonSaucy
on Apr 10, 2012
Internet Explorer 10 is in beta so the numbers there don't count as there might be debug code / non-optimized code in there. It might be even faster when it's "official". Even so, to all intents and purposes all the ten browsers listed are more than fast enough. Google Chrome concerns me though, as it is basically spyware. I wouldn't use it. It is nice to see the oft knocked, under appreciated IE at the top of the list. People keep thinking IE6, but really, in IE9's case, it's the safest and fastest of the bunch. Safari, for crying out loud, still suffers from drive-bys. IE9, in contrast, runs in protected mode. IE, you've come a long way baby!
Fuller1754
on Oct 17, 2012
I use IE 9/10 and Chrome (I've pretty much given up on Firefox). I like IE quite a bit, and I didn't think I'd ever say that, but I lean more heavily towards Chrome for a very simple reason: Chrome stores my bookmarks and settings on the cloud. Wheneverand I do believe it will comewhenever I can "sign in" to IE with my MS account so that my bookmarks and settings follow me around, then IE will be a real attractive option.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use