Anatomy of a headline: Xbox 360 parental controls

So this week, Microsoft announced that it was adding a new feature to its Xbox 360 video game console that will allow parents to determine how much time their kids can play games on the device. Put simply, they're improving the device's parental controls. It's unclear how this can be seen as a bad thing, and ZD's headline about this news item is typical:

Microsoft aims to make Xbox more family-friendly

Microsoft on Wednesday showed off a new Xbox feature that will allow parents to set the amount of time that kids can play games. The move is part of the company's effort to broaden the reach of the Xbox 360 to include more families. 

Fair enough. But it's interesting to me how a Microsoft-unfriendly publication, like the acerbic UK-based Inquirer, handles this same story. Here's their headline:

Microsoft censors Xbox 360

See the difference? Now, we've all played with headlines to some extent. (The one I did that I still smile over is, "Is that a PC in Your Pocket or are You Happy to CE?") But this one just plays off of a needless Microsoft hatred. The sub-heading, "for the good of the children," ladles on a little sarcasm, just so you know it's all just good, clean fun. Except that it's not. Here's an example:

The big idea is to make the console more attractive to parents who love torturing their children with autocratic and dictatorial controls under the guise of preservation. This is a big market across the pond ... The new function is similar to one installed in Windows Vista which is designed to stop adults wasting all their day searching for porn. The new timer can be set to limit playing time on a daily or weekly basis.

Here's the thing. I love British humor. Love it. Get it. Recommend it. This isn't it. In fact, this isn't humor at all. It's just spiteful and silly. 

Discuss this Article 5

cesjr
on Nov 9, 2007
It's a little weird to see this type of "bias analysis" being done be Paul when he engages in the same type of slanted reporting almost on a daily basis.
weedmonk
on Nov 9, 2007
Dont you have somewhere else you can tr0ll cesjr? We all know you have your tongue lodged deem up steve jobs' ass....why don't you continue to wait on the next steamy juicy iTurd that he may pinch out. Its really sad you macboi's have to continue to b!tch and moan about every post Paul makes. There's no PC wars except in your irrelevant iBubble.
cesjr
on Nov 9, 2007
Weedmonk - Dont you have anything to work with besides 5-year-old level name-calling and toilet jokes?
bugfaceuk
on Nov 9, 2007
It is terrible when someone takes something which is at worst neutral news, and a best, a genuinely useful feature that parents can use (I is one) and twists it with negative spin to score petty points.
DRWAM
on Nov 10, 2007
Dumb Headline. MS uses valuable resources and chances adding bugs to software, in order to make a product that parents can set limits in order to preserve the family is a good thing. Good work MS! Of course I have the same control on my kids computer, it's called the off switch. But with this control, I don't need to be home. The family unit must be preserved. I'll quit rather than climb on a soapbox, but ya know what I'm talkin' bout. I wonder how many other companies have such technology.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use