Macworld 2009: My iPhone dilemma

In about 10 minutes, Apple will keynote its last Macworld trade show. For a variety of reasons—Steve Jobs’ inadequately explained new illness, the lack of Jobs at the show, the fact that Apple is leaving after this year—this Macworld is less interesting than most. But I’m still going to be hanging on Phil Schiller’s every word. Because I do have some things I’m curious about. And one of them affects a device I use every day: The iPhone.

Listeners of the Windows Weekly podcast know that I’m interesting in pursuing what I jokingly called “La Vida Microsoft.” This is the SuperSite for Windows, after all, and it seems like I should be focusing first and foremost of Microsoft technologies, especially those that directly impact Windows users. On that note, I’ve been using the Zune exclusively instead of the iPod, for example. (And loving it.) But I’ve been unable to get away from the iPhone. Despite it’s remaining flaws, and there are many (though Apple has dramatically improved the device over the past 18 months), the iPhone is simply the best smart phone there is, and by a wide margin.

That said, data syncing is still a huge problem on the iPhone, for Windows users, a situation where I still feel that I’m the only person out there even communicating this problem. Ideally, I’d be able to sync my Windows Live contacts and calendar directly (i.e. over the air) to the iPhone, but that’s impossible from what I can tell. Not as good, but acceptable, I’d be able to indirectly sync this information to the phone through Outlook on a PC. That, at best, is difficult, and for a variety of reasons.

So. What I’m doing right now is synching contacts via Apple’s lackluster (but, again, getting better) MobileMe service and syncing my Google Calendar via the excellent NuevaSync service. I would be synching Google Gmail Contacts via NuevaSync but I’ve run into a bug getting the master contacts list imported. (This bug doesn’t affect my secondary Google account, so I suspect it will be rectified over time.) Syncing things through Google OTA to the iPhone is good but not great, and getting off of MobileMe is also desirable. Coincidentally, my MobileMe account runs out this week, so depending on the announcements I hear at Macworld, I may finally get rid of it.

Anyway. I’m curious to see if there are any MobileMe/iPhone/Apple online services announcements today. Secondarily, I’d like to figure out a way to get Windows Live data synced to the iPhone. I don’t expect any news in that regard today.

I’m curious if Apple is serious about putting iLife on the Web for everyone to use and what effect, if any, this will have on Microsoft digital media offerings (Windows Live Movie Maker, etc.).

I’m curious is Apple is really entering the home server market, following Microsoft yet again. I doubt they will do this as it doesn’t seem like a good idea, and Apple TV (which is excellent now) hasn’t really set the world on fire, so why bother?

I’m only a little bit interested in a new Mac Mini and only then if it’s truly competitive from a price standpoint. I don’t expect much there.

I’m even less interested in a 17-inch Macbook Pro with a non-removable battery and Apple’s typically over-inflated battery life claims, but that seems to be on the docket as well.

I do expect Apple to announce stellar holiday sales and brag about typically dubious market share claims. I expect the bogus “world’s greenest laptop” claims to continue too.

Well. I guess we’ll see what happens. These are my thoughts and questions about the show before it happens. I won’t be able to do something similar for CES, and Steve Ballmer’s keynote tomorrow, because I’ve already been briefed on that. But it will be interesting to compare the two keynotes, since (among other things) both are lacking their long-term presenters for the first time.

Discuss this Article 75

mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
I'm waiting for the MacBook Wheel!
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
Hmm iPhoto 09 sure looks like it's trying to catch up with Windows Live Photo Gallery.
DRWAM
on Jan 6, 2009
Paul, try downloading Saisuke Free on your iPhone, at the app store of course. It's the free version and will sync with your Google calendar, but is restricted to the current two weeks. I was able to sync many more weeks by back dating or forward dating my iPhone's date every two weeks, then syncing Saisuke [I was waiting for the kids to get their XMAS pics, so I had plenty of time]. I now have the $9.99 version of Saisuke. I like the monthly view of the calendar with text, sorta like DateBK 6 on a Palm.
tayme
on Jan 6, 2009
@Paul - You should try the Samsung Omnia...if you don't hate Verizon...and I know some people do. Other than the lockout from the GPS, which it is rumored that Verizon is going to open that up this year, I have loved the experience of the Omnia and WinMo 6.1. I still think that the "One more thing" this year will be an appearance by Jobs...once again proving that Apple will use anything for the Hype Factor...even a man's health. --tayme
puzder
on Jan 6, 2009
What is Paul's beef with the Blackberry? Apart from the fact that it has the same issues with syncing as the iPhone.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
iMovie 09 or "Please pretend iMovie 08 didn't happen" (But it'll be interesting to see how the image stabilization works in real life rather than in demos)
SandmanX82
on Jan 6, 2009
"iPhoto 09 sure looks like it's trying to catch up with Windows Live Photo Gallery." And Picasa "it'll be interesting to see how the image stabilization works in real life rather than in demos" It'll probably actually be pretty decent. They probably just took SmoothCam from Final Cut Pro.
maati
on Jan 6, 2009
Paul, why not get this phone: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xg2XlNNt3vE It's better than the iPhone in every aspect.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
Garage Band 09 - Learn to play the piano in 9 easy lessons + Celebrities tell you how to play a song for only $5
maati
on Jan 6, 2009
The HTC Touch HD has everything that the iPhone lacks. No problems with syncing, no missing features like bluetooth file transfer. It's completely customizable thanks to Windows Mobile AND, as you can see in this video, Windows Mobile is not slow at all.
Lindy
on Jan 6, 2009
I read that iWork was going to possibly have a web component but not iLife. iWork 09 with google doc/cloud access. Apple may exaggerate their battery life times, but dam OS X gets way more life than Vista....WAY MORE, on the same size battery. My 14 month old Macbook gets 3+ hours even now. It got very close to 4 or 4 when I first got it.
DRWAM
on Jan 6, 2009
I never had a problem syncing my iPhone, and I transfer files over WiFi pretty darn quick, from any where in my home. WiFi does have a better range than BT ya know. But hey, life and this site is not without FUD.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
iWork - what can I say when outlining, mail merge, full screen view and the ability to live link spreadsheet data into a document are keynote-level features... Very retro. I think I saw this demo in 1985.
Lindy
on Jan 6, 2009
iwork.com it is.
Lindy
on Jan 6, 2009
"iWork - what can I say when outlining, mail merge, full screen view and the ability to live link spreadsheet data into a document are keynote-level features... Very retro. I think I saw this demo in 1985." Did it cost $79 even in 1985?
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
iWork.com, Apple's version of what Office Live did long ago (but with all that MobileMe goodness) But, since it's in beta they must be going after Google Docs.
tayme
on Jan 6, 2009
I can do that Spotlight thing on my Omnia...with PowerPoint Mobile. In fact, with the purcahse of a $15 cable, I can connect the Omnia to a projector and away it goes...up on the big screen. --tayme
maati
on Jan 6, 2009
Paul, your blog doesn't update within Safari. It still shows that "New folder icons in Windows 7?" post on the main page. It would probably update if I deleted the cookies but there's definitely something wrong with Safari and your site. And once again: Get rid of that iPhone and get an HTC device.
SandmanX82
on Jan 6, 2009
Ouch...looks like the iWork.com beta is free, but...."eventually it will be a pay service."
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
Oh, and iWork.com will be fee based once it comes out of beta.
tayme
on Jan 6, 2009
@Lindy - "Did it cost $79 even in 1985?" $15 for me today...see my earlier post. --tayme
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
On to the hardware. MacBook Pro 17" For only $50 extra, you can have a matte screen that Apple previously insisted nobody wanted and professionals told them shouldn't exist.
daveinla
on Jan 6, 2009
I’m interesting in pursuing what I jokingly called “La Vida Microsoft.” You received an note from MS that you were a bit too obsessed with Apple gear ?? "I’m curious to see if there are any MobileMe/iPhone/Apple online services announcements today I’m curious if Apple is serious about putting iLife I’m curious is Apple is ... " Off to a bad bad start for la vida Microsoft... Truth is it's a tough choice nowadays for a digital home user to live la Vida Microsoft ! But good luck.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
And as a new "feature" a non-removable battery on your professional device!
Lindy
on Jan 6, 2009
No mini? Man that is going to cause a stir, I mean 17inch notebook sales have got to be the lowest of any group.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
And, yes, they really spent five full minutes of the keynote talking about battery design...
Ymaster587
on Jan 6, 2009
@Mike Hoo boy, if that isn't flame baiting I'm not sure what is...
tayme
on Jan 6, 2009
DRM Free music...that is a good thing, I guess. But, I'll stick with my Zune Pass because just having it on 3 PCs and 3 devices is enough for me. Plus I get 10 free per month to do with as I see fit. --tayme
chipwinter
on Jan 6, 2009
Mike, I haven't used Windows Live Photo Gallery (not much of a photo guy). My daughter uses iPhoto on her Mac. In what areas is Apple playing catch-up?
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
chip, Face tagging is one area.
RunTimeError
on Jan 6, 2009
mikegalos: "And, yes, they really spent five full minutes of the keynote talking about battery design..." Yes, yes. And you have spent an hour and a half posting witticisms in the comments section of a blog.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
So much for Steve Jobs' 1 price for any music on iTunes. Still, it's nice to see them finally drop DRM.
tayme
on Jan 6, 2009
Geez, Tony Bennett looks as bad as Steve Jobs does, only older!!! I am glad I bought my 17" MBP when I did...I don't need or want what they are offering on this new one. --tayme
Lindy
on Jan 6, 2009
Man no mini, that was sad. I would guess the DRM free music was the biggest news. It will take the wind out of amazon pretty quick, especially with new price points. Overall not that big of a deal. I imagine the mini is dead or will be announced by Apple only this quarter?
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
RunTimeError, Just my way of doing a Reality Reinforcement Field.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
So, in short: What didn't happen: No new Mac Mini, No new iMacs, No new Mac Pro, No new iPhone Nano, No new iPhone Pro, No new Apple TV, No new products, No surprise appearance by Steve Jobs What did ship? Enhancements to: iLife, iWork, MacBook Pro 17", iTunes...
LC21
on Jan 6, 2009
Slow day, Microsoft Mike? Nothing to do but cheap shot Apple? I use MS Office on a MacBook every day. Couldn't live without it. Adults can take advantage of the strengths of both platforms, losing the need to obsessively run the other down. Try it some time.
DRWAM
on Jan 6, 2009
Is it over? Two thumbs down. At least there was no iPhone nano. I just upgraded my wife's phone [she wanted a small phone], but a nano may have appealed to her. I would have been unhappy if it came to be. Now my apologies for not reading about the sync problem. I was wrong. What I do is sync Outlook to Google calender [thanks to Mike G. He's the man] which updates as often as I select, one way or two way sync. Then sync with Saisuke, a much better calendar for me than the iPhone's calendar, although iPhone's cal sync with Exchange perfectly for me, including contacts, OTA. Exchange syncs with Entourage too. And of course, it was this site, especially Mike G, that encouraged me to use it. Mike, that's two 'you da man's in one post. Yes, my pipe dream is syncing with Windows Live too.
chipwinter
on Jan 6, 2009
I think the bar is now set pretty low for Ballmer. Unfortunately I don't have any confidence he'll be able to do better than this. Anybody got any ideas?
chipwinter
on Jan 6, 2009
Thanks Mike. I don't have enough photos to tag, but I see where that would be important. As for Windows Live Photo Gallery, do they offer face recognition, or is this face-tagging based on user input (I know ... I could look it up, but you seem to know and are much quicker)?
RunTimeError
on Jan 6, 2009
tayme: Semi-agreed; I don't need/want some of what's offered in he new 17" MBP, but I'd sure love to be able to stuff another 4GB of ram in this thing :)
shark47
on Jan 6, 2009
Picasa offers face recognition. I don't thin Live Photos does.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
Oh, and no new Mac Home Server or improved iPhone sync. (The things Paul said he was interested in)
lotsamystuff
on Jan 6, 2009
"I still think that the "One more thing" this year will be an appearance by Jobs...once again proving that Apple will use anything for the Hype Factor...even a man's health." Come on, "tayme". You're above that. I expect sh** like that from Waethorn or "mikegalos", not you.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 6, 2009
tayme The difference is Tony Bennett is 82. Steve Jobs is 53. And the other difference is that everybody I know who has met Tony Bennett really likes him and says he's a great guy.
shark47
on Jan 6, 2009
"Anybody got any ideas?" He'll announce the Zune Mobile with free international calling, wireless, and song downloads on Dec 31st of a leap year.
tayme
on Jan 6, 2009
@"lotsamystuff" - Nope...I call it like I seed it. I really did think that JObs was going to make an appearance...and for the reason that I stated. Apple is nothing, if not a good PR machine! Of course, I'm not saying that is all that they are...but they do(or at least did) value showmanship. --tayme
tayme
on Jan 6, 2009
Oops...I didn't mean that i "seed" it...that'd be gross. Now, our new bonch, robertsjoe...I am sure that he did seed it. --tayme
tayme
on Jan 6, 2009
@shaky - Good one. But, I am looking forward to Zune Mobile. --tayme
FlyerMike
on Jan 6, 2009
Can you get an HTC Touch HD with US 3G anywhere yet?

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use