SuperSite Blog Daily Update: November 29, 2010

Good morning.

The New York Times asks, "With so much going for them why, eight months after the iPad's release, is the design of so many of those apps so boring?"

To which I answer: They're boring because the iPad is boring.

Rather than create an environment that was specially tailored to the unique iPad form factor, Apple instead chose to simply stretch the iPhone UI out to meet the size of the new device, making only small changes to accommodate the additional onscreen real estate. And now app developers are aping Apple, as they always do.

Put another way, there's no real innovation on the iPad, just a desire to sell stuff from one place in another place. And that's as true of Apple as it is of the developers. Raise your hand if you paid, again, for an "HD" version of an iPhone app on the iPad.

--

Google rocketed to fame and fortune must faster than did Microsoft. And now its running into a wall much faster than Microsoft did, too.

Google, which only 12 years ago was a scrappy start-up in a garage, now finds itself viewed in Silicon Valley as the big, lumbering incumbent. Inside the company some of its best engineers are chafing under the growing bureaucracy and are leaving to start or work at smaller, nimbler companies.

But my favorite quote comes, as always, from Google's curiously stupefying CEO. He makes Steve Ballmer look calm and rational by comparison.

"We hire more people in a week than go to Facebook in its lifetime," Mr. Schmidt said, dismissing the idea that Facebook was poaching Google's best people.

It's about quality, not quantity. Obviously.

--

Microsoft has finalized its Visual Basic add-on for the Windows Phone Developer Tools.

--

Kenny Kerr has released Window Clippings 3, the new version of his popular screen capture tool for Windows Vista and 7.

Discuss this Article 7

chuckb84
on Nov 29, 2010

"Google rocketed to fame and fortune must faster than did Microsoft. And now its running into a wall much faster than Microsoft did, too."

Doubtful. There is still plenty of room to innovate on the interwebs, certainly more room than there is in the desktop OS and Office space, which is the Microsoft bread and butter.

It's also odd that you post that Google is running into a wall while Android is running away with much of the Phone OS market. The image in Microsoft's rearview mirror is now Google. Already consigned to second place in marketcap behind Apple, it looks at least possible that Microsoft will fall to 3rd, behind Google.

www.wolframalpha.com/input

Change the graph to the last 10 years and use a log scale; you'll see the trend.

meason
on Nov 29, 2010

I think many of the "Boring" apps for iOS go directly back to the approval process and using objective C

1) the Approval process forces developers not to take risks with overly innovative things.  Why make the investment in a great app ui experience only to have apple squash it because you void some design pattern or some other such rule.

2)objective C..... lots of developers are just not going to go out and learn it well enough to do great thigns...... how many places outside of apple is it used?  As I have said before whats the ratio of JAVA/.Net developers to Apple Developers? 100 -1 or worse?

  That is why I think long term you will see Windows Phone 7 development go a lot further.  You have a very familiar framework used by millions of developers that need to do very little to use it.  

lehenbauer
on Nov 29, 2010

If only we could convince the 4.2 million people who bought iPads in the third quarter how boring it is and somehow get that message out to the 6.5M to 7M people who will buy one in the fourth quarter (eWeek) then we can rescue ten million people from boredom.

Why don't those fools understand how boring and non-innovative the iPad is?  Why won't Apple come to their senses and "create an environment that is specifically tailored to the unique iPad form factor"?

daveinla
on Nov 29, 2010

The iPad is boring ??!?

Well it's a bit more useful than the Kindle you're so fond of. Actually at home it's the first device used when one of our family member wants to check something on the web or do games. It's also the one and only device we now pack when going on vacations because the kids gets so entertained with it and it's the most compact and elegant way to keep in touch with mails and the web.

Mum
on Nov 29, 2010

I'll come back to think about your comment that there's no real innovation on the iPad once the first real competitors to the tablet computer scene are out, hopefully at matching prices.

But that won't be too soon.

jvd897
on Nov 30, 2010

I'm not sure the iPad is boring, but it's certainly not as innovative as it could be, at least not from a UI perspective.

My ideal tablet would be a portable implementation of the Microsoft Surface that would accommodate not only touch but also ink, voice, and even keyboard and mouse input. There seems to be a hatred for the keyboard and mouse amongst some iOS and Apple zealots, but these are still useful in many scenarios. As Bill Buxton notes, "Everything is best for something and worst for something else.

The trick is knowing for what, when, for whom, and why."

cibertek
on Dec 1, 2010
It might be boring for you or even some folks but the rest of 4.2MIL who bought one will probably disagree. I am one of them. I only have one IPAD and it sits at home. When I get home, it is usually the first item I pickup and use before I turn on the TV. Does it need improvements? Of course it does and I hope Apple will do everything you yourself has proposed to make it better.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use