LG Made Windows Phones?

LG made a bit of news today by revealing that it was disappointed in sales of its Windows Phone handsets and thus wouldn’t be making any new devices for the foreseeable future. Some are looking at this news as yet more evidence of that Windows Phone is doomed. But I just have one question.

Wait, LG made Windows Phones?

I’m only half joking. No offense to LG, but the firm made exactly one Windows Phone handset for the US market, the LG Quantum, and it was the least interesting device that was part of the initial Windows Phone launch in 2010. (There was also an LG Optimus 7 for international markets.) Since then, two new generations of Windows Phone handsets have arrived, most recently with the LTE-equipped Nokia Lumia 900 and HTC Titan 2.

And, I’m sorry, you think LG leaving this market is bad news? After that pathetic showing? Please.

Companies that make boring and generic phones as LG does deserve to be lost in the sea of look-alike, work-alike Android clones. And it’s not surprising that LG is falling on hard times financially, as even its Android phones don’t sell well. Meanwhile, Samsung, which wouldn’t win a single design award for its Windows Phone lineup, has made three very credible Windows Phone handsets for the US market alone.

But LG? Come on. They weren’t even trying. 


Discuss this Article 11

Mustang17
on Apr 30, 2012
In complete contrast, here is a reviewer who is somewhat delighted with his recently delivered Lumia 900. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hDOHG1r62xI&feature=related Yep, I think he likes it..
Waethorn
on Apr 30, 2012
Paul, I'm not exactly enamored with anything that Samsung makes. Their TV's are extremely unreliable and don't last, their hard drives are defective and generally don't last the full length of warranty (and it shows in the fact that they're cheaper than everybody else), and their optical drives don't impress either. Both make PC's that are surprisingly overpriced, but not surprisingly underpowered. LG is not much better in reliability where they overlap Samsung, so I equate them with each other. Both companies make cheap sh**.
gorath
on Apr 30, 2012
There's something that's always bugged me about phone sales. It's common for a phone to be released exclusively on a particular carrier network - when in fact that often artificially limits the choice of phones available. There's been a few phones released which I've had an interest in trying, but since they're not on my network - which happens to be the only viable option in terms of signal round here - then they're immediately out of the question. It's about time handset manufacturers became carrier agnostic.
edwilson.sousa
on Apr 30, 2012
Here (Brazil), LG never putted a Windows Phone to sell.. a strategic country to Samsung and Nokia is simply ignored by LG.
ianaldrighetti
on Apr 30, 2012
@gorath I have no idea whether this is true or not, but are you sure it is the device makers that don't want to be carrier agnostic? I would think it would be in the best interest of the device makers to have say, device X, on as many networks as possible... However, the carriers best interest would be the complete opposite: to be the only one with device X. That way if a person wants it, they would have to come to their network. While that may not be good enough for certain people to switch, you have to think it has some merit to it (especially for new customers who don't have a phone at all). I would think that the carriers may pay a bit more for the phones, or pay an upfront fee, to get a device exclusive. As I said, I could be wrong, but that sounds more likely to me.
gorath
on May 1, 2012
@Aldrighetti I'm pretty sure that it is the carriers that want exclusivity, but the handset makers should just put their foot down and refuse such nonsense. It's bad for them, it's bad for the consumer, and it's certainly not good for the free market.
ronmcmahon
on May 1, 2012
Paul, your assertion that the LG Optimus was the most boring of the Windows Phones sounds more like sour grapes than an informed opinion. In Canada Bell Mobility was the only carrier to offer a Windows Phone with a physical keyboard, the LG Optimus C900B. In my opinion it was the best of the first generation Windows Phones BECAUSE it had the real keyboard. I'm not sure if there are any physical keyboard-based Windows Phones left on the market, and that is a problem for customers like myself who want such a feature. The biggest issue with what I'm ready to concede as the failure of Windows Phone in the marketplace is Microsoft's absolute lack of developer support (at least here in Canada). I was at last year's Tech-Ed where Microsoft and Nokia were giving away handsets to developers who would promise to develop for the platform, but sorry, not in Canada. Over the last year I've contacted Microsoft Canada twice about handset support and have been ignored. The retail marketplace here is dominated by Best Buy and Future Shop and you rarely see a Windows Phone included in their weekly flyers. So as a company Microsoft has failed to back up its words of support for Canadian developers with hardware and it has failed to spend as necessary in the marketplace to better push its product. I say this as someone who DID spend my own money to get on the early Windows Phone train, but as my first app nears completion I'm focusing my development time on the iPhone platform first, followed next by Android and Blackberry. I wanted to go Windows Phone first but I don't see why Microsoft deserves my effort if they aren't prepared to be a participating partner in OUR success.
pthurrott
on May 1, 2012
No, it's based on using all of the first gen US-based devices. It was the least interesting by far.
ModernDislocation
on May 1, 2012
So, LG is the second handset maker to drop Windows (Dell begin the first). Not a good trend for MS.
mog0
on May 2, 2012
I bought an LG Optimus 7 as it was cheap and had 16GB of storage, whereas all the other handsets only had 8GB. Unfortunately my experience of the handset it that it's CHEAP. The phone signal strength is rubbish, often leaving me without any connection at all, including once when my car broke down! The WiFi signal strength is also very poor, the e-compass never works. I can turn through 360degrees and it only moves by 30 (I've tried calibrating many times, it only gets worse!) and I recently bought Navigon's sat-nav for it...It frequently loses it's GPS signal and often thinks I'm in a field several hundred yards away from the road (also found that it happens when I'm using bing maps as well, it's not the Navigon software). On top of all this, they promised at launch to release new free software every month in their own store and I think they've released 1 or 2 in the last 15 months so they've broken their own promises. My friend bought an LG handset a year before me (not windows phone) and had so many problems with it he recommended I not buy one and I wish I listened. I will NEVER buy another LG handset so them pulling out is not a big deal for me. The only light on the horizon is that my contract runs out in November and so should be just the right timing for me to get a new Apollo based win phone and hopefully get away from the crap hardware I'm currently stuck with. p.s. I love the software on my phone, it's just the hardware that's crap.
fjarlq
on May 3, 2012
Windows Phone is starting to take off. Almost doubled its market share since the holidays: http://marketshare.hitslink.com/report.aspx?qprid=9&qpcustom=Windows+Pho... The rest of the field: http://marketshare.hitslink.com/report.aspx?qprid=9&qpcustomb=1

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use