Patch Tuesday Surprises: Surface Firmware Updates, IE 10 Flash Reversal

Firmware updates for Surface Pro and Surface RT and a reversal of how IE 10 handles Flash

I don’t normally report on each month’s set of “Patch Tuesday” updates since it’s mostly just security updates that everyone should be installing automatically. But this month includes three surprises, including firmware updates for both the Surface Pro and Surface RT tablets, and a major update to Internet Explorer 10 that completely reverses the way this browser handles Adobe Flash.

Firmware update for Surface Pro

The most notable of these updates, perhaps, is the first-ever firmware update for Microsoft’s Surface with Windows 8 Pro tablet. This update, dubbed the March update, includes the following changes, according to Microsoft:

·         Fixes to Wi-Fi reliability allowing for better roaming and improvements to "Limited" connectivity scenarios.

·         Windows To Go feature is enabled.

·         Improved onscreen keyboard detection synchronization when going in and out of sleep.

If it’s unclear why this is a big deal, Windows To Go is normally a feature of Windows 8 Enterprise only. Another reason to choose Surface Pro?

Firmware update for Surface RT

Surface RT’s fourth firmware update—the device first shipped back in October 2012, so there’s been one every month since—is also called the March update. This one includes the following changes:

·         Fixes to Wi-Fi reliability allowing for better roaming and improvements to "Limited" connectivity scenarios.

·         Resolves issues with integrated volume button.

·         Improved Type and Touch cover typing experience on soft surfaces and when devices and keyboard are lying flat.

·         Resolves issue with random muting.

·         Trackpad performance improvements.

Internet Explorer 10 + Flash

I wrote a news story about this yesterday—see Microsoft Flip-Flop Fixes Flash—but Microsoft also delivered a very interesting update for Internet Explorer 10 for Windows 8 and Windows RT. Basically, it completely changes how the browser handles Adobe Flash on these two operating systems.

To be clear, this change impacts the “Metro” version of IE 10 on Windows 8 and both the Metro and desktop versions of IE 10 on Windows RT. This change does not affect IE 10 on Windows 7, nor does it affect the desktop version of IE 10 on Windows 8.

If you’ve been following the Flash drama for the past few years, you may recall that Microsoft first stated its intention to focus primarily on HTML 5 for web-based video delivery almost three years ago in a post to the IEBlog called, appropriately enough, HTML5 Video. At the time, IE GM Dean Hachamovitch said that Flash had some issues around reliability, security, and performance, and that Flash was “an important part of delivering a good consumer experience on today’s web.”

In May 2012, Rafael Rivera and I wrote about Microsoft’s plans to include Flash as part of IE 10 in Windows 8 Secrets: Internet Explorer 10 will Ship with Adobe Flash. That Microsoft would actually embed a subset of Flash in its own browser was quite surprising, as was the news that it would create a white list called the Compatibility View list that would contain the only Flash-based sites that would work in the Metro versions of IE 10 in Windows 8/RT (and the desktop IE 10 in RT).

Of course, lots of people didn’t like this decision. So this week’s change, which literally amounts to a total reversal of the previous policy, is quite interesting indeed. Now, IE 10 will allow all Flash sites to work, except for those that are in the Compatibility View list. So that CV list has effectively switched from a white list to a black list.

“We are updating Internet Explorer 10 in Windows 8 and Windows RT to enable Flash content to run by default,” Microsoft group program manager Rob Mauceri explains in a post to the IEBlog. “On Windows 8, all Flash content continues to be enabled for IE on the desktop … Of the thousands of domains tested for Flash compatibility to date, we have found fewer than 4 percent are still incompatible, in the most part because the core site experience requires other ActiveX controls in addition to Flash … With today’s update to Windows 8 and Windows RT, consumers can experience more of the Web by default.”

It’s interesting that the three issues that Hachamovitch originally raises about Flash three years ago—reliability, security, and performance—are still the issues we’re concerned with today. But it appears that Flash is too important to ignore, despite the continued evolution of HTML 5-based video online. Somewhere Steve Jobs must be very unhappy with this.

Discuss this Article 18

MonkeyMarsh
on Mar 12, 2013

Hi - think there is a typo in the following:

"Surface RT’s fourth firmware update—the device first shipped back in October 2010" - should this be October 2012?

GoodThings2Life
on Mar 12, 2013

It's a very interesting reversal indeed. Flash is one of those technologies that NEEDS to die, and that is possibly the only point in which I ever agreed with Steve Jobs about.

But I do feel this acknowledges not only the complaints/criticisms raised by customers but also addresses a point you've made... if you don't have the apps, the next best (and perhaps better) thing is to have a full-blown web experience, and for that to be true... Flash is still necessary.

I actually wonder if they'll do the same for Silverlight, since it's such a minimal impact on the web. My only other big concern is the number of sites that require Java.

ian.aldrighetti
on Mar 12, 2013

I'm interested in hearing which websites require Java. I don't remember the last time I used a website that needed Java.

TraderGary
on Mar 13, 2013

I trade with Interactive Brokers and use their software trading platform. It requires Java.

bradwestness
on Mar 12, 2013

Flash couldn't die too soon in my opinion, but this does give the Surface a pretty big advantage over iOS based devices, so it's not hard to see why Microsoft did it.

Browser plugins on the whole are largely a bad thing, but the fact is there are still a ton of sites that require Flash, so this is a welcome change - for Windows RT users especially.

ScubaDog2008
on Mar 13, 2013

I couldn't agree with you more. I hate Flash, I try to resist using anything from Adobe, in fact. I'm must so sick of bloated programs when there are much more lightweight alternatives that people just refuse to migrate to.

king
on Mar 12, 2013

The Surface RT did not ship in 2010. It was 2012. Small typo.

pthurrott
on Mar 12, 2013

Thanks for the typo reports, guys. Fixed.

jhoff80
on Mar 12, 2013

I agree that the Flash thing is a surprise, but the Surface RT has been getting firmware updates every Patch Tuesday, so I'm not sure why it and the Surface Pro getting an update today would be a surprise.

As for Flash, I'd prefer the option to have it off by default, and then you click on the element to enable it only in that element, similar to how Flashblock for Firefox and Chrome works.

BillG
on Mar 12, 2013

They now allow Flash, but not Silverlight for Photosynth.net a Microsoft site

saqrkh
on Mar 12, 2013

Given Microsoft's rationale now with Flash...is there a reason to *not* have it on Windows Phone?

winkwink
on Mar 13, 2013

Yea, why not?

saqrkh
on Mar 13, 2013

They might as well include it in Windows Phone 9. As much as I'd like to see HTML5 become the standard for media delivery, Flash is still too prolific to ignore.

If we had Flash on Windows Phone IE I could browse onto CityTV/CTV/Global and stream catch-up episodes, stream live news, etc. Having Flash would bring a bit of app parity in multimedia, and for many first-time smartphone users, it'd be a pleasant experience to see their phone browser be as functional as that of their PC.

S Rowland
on Mar 13, 2013

The Windows-to-go addition is curious. Does this give Microsoft a feature advantage over the other OEMs? Doesn't quite seem fair play!

thundr35
on Mar 13, 2013

Thinking the same thing! Honestly, I don't see why they wouldn't allow this on devices/PCs that are running Win8Pro

Lopan
on Mar 14, 2013

I'm claiming personal responsibility for raising awareness of this issue with MS "Improved onscreen keyboard detection synchronization when going in and out of sleep.". This issue has been really irritating me. Every time the system went to sleep the state of the Type cover connectedness was never properly detected. Causing me to have to re-attach my Type cover when ever it was disconnected while in sleep mode just to get my pin/pass typed in and further be able to use the onscreen keyboard. I'm applying the update now and will report if it actually works.

charms55
on Mar 14, 2013

This is the third update promising a fix to the Limited problem with WiFi on my Surface. Still, I have to restart when coming HOME???? I don't get this one. Why is this fix so tough?

Code4Sale
on Mar 20, 2013

I am not alone when the update bricked by Asus Vivo Tab. Bought a Surface RT as an emergency replacement, only to find it was one of the many defective Surface RT units sold where the SD slot does not mount unless you hold the sd card all the way in (and it un-mounts when you let go and the card locks in). If you have a Surface RT, be sure to test the Micro SD slot to see if you too have a defective unit.

BTW Paul: your email verification system needs to be kicked... it is not sending the verification emails...

BTWx2 Paul: You site accepts images that can have approx a thousand bytes per pixel??? "Your virtual face or picture. Maximum dimensions are 61x70 and the maximum size is 4096 kB"... wow.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use