NOOK for Windows 8/RT … And Some Thoughts About NOOK

NOOK looks good ... But it's no Kindle

Barnes & Noble has released the NOOK app for Windows 8 and RT, so if you’re a NOOK customer, you’ll want to check that out. But I’ll be sitting this one out, sorry: I just prefer Kindle.

On a related note, I get a lot of questions about whether I’d ever consider a NOOK tablet (over an Amazon, Apple, or Windows-type device) or use the NOOK eBook platform instead of Kindle. The answer to both is no.

Amazon’s Kindle platform is bigger and stronger, and I’ve been an Amazon customer for years. The firm has created one of the best content ecosystems on earth—arguably on par with Apple’s—and Kindle is of course just a part of that. A key part, but a part.

B&N’s NOOK devices, while occasionally interesting—the NOOK HD+ is, for now at least, one of the best full-sized tablets in the market—seem like a response to other innovators, something the firm got into almost begrudgingly. But more important, to me, is that I have no faith in the company’s ability to survive. And when I look at the mobile computing platforms of the future, I see iOS, Android, Amazon (which we might also just call “Kindle”) and Windows. It is interesting to me that Amazon has been able to carve out a market for itself by subverting Android. I don’t see B&N doing that with NOOK.

So, no hard feelings. I’m just not interested.

 

Discuss this Article 10

ian.aldrighetti
on Nov 14, 2012

Would you change your mind if B&N formed a closer relationship with Microsoft? Perhaps say a Windows 8 based NOOK?

rjohn05
on Nov 14, 2012

I'm interested because I love a good underdog comeback story!

GO NOOK!

mikemuch
on Nov 14, 2012

Not so on the innovation. Nook was first with a touch eInk device, first with a backlit tablet (before AMZN), first with a backlit eInk reader. And the Nook HD has the highest pixel density of any 7" tablet--even higher than the iPad Mini. Has a faster processor than Fire, too: look up spec comparisons (your comment system wouldn't accept links) But one thing I think is clearly better about nook books is that they use actual page numbers that correspond with the printed book--Kindle uses a useless percent.

JimmyFal
on Nov 14, 2012

Then I would be overly interested in your opinion of the Kindle app on the Surface RT. Is it just me or is it absolute crap?

I would like to think that I could pinch to zoom and possibly infinitely scroll through book text. The app is a horror show an totally unusable. Sometimes it takes 5 to 10 seconds to turn a page.

If you tell me otherwise, then I will uninstall and reinstall the app. Maybe I should do that anyway. Thanks, JF

pthurrott
on Nov 14, 2012

No, you're right. The Kindle app on Windows 8 is only OK, not great. I don't read on full-sized tablets, so I won't be using this. But ... yeah.

NarcoSleepy
on Nov 14, 2012

The Kindle app for RT is awful. Among the things you mentioned, I have several PDFs that I have on my account, but Amazon will not let me synchronize them to any of my devices other than the Kindle itself.

rth314
on Nov 15, 2012

Like Paul, I put my money into the Kindle ecosystem, but I am envious of the Nook app for Windows 8. The Nook app even allows you to browse books for purchase within the app. The clunky Kindle app kicks you out to the browser to view their ugly website. I may use e-ink to read, but I like a big tablet to read childrens books to my kids. And I'd like to easily find similar books within the app for easy purchase.

mistagreg
on Nov 16, 2012

I have this thing about going to the book store. I love to hang out, get a coffee, look at books, attend a signing, etc. I want bn to survive. I bought a nook and consciously split my buying between paper and cloud in an effort to keep it alive.

It helped alot that the Nook app is much better for me than the Kindle app. Although Paul is right about the ecosystem, I'm trying to keep it alive for a little while longer.

-Greg

Ford Warrick Jr
on Nov 19, 2012

I agree that Barnes and Noble is in a more precarious financial position than Amazon. Amazon is huge. Like Greg commented above, I appreciate that Barnes and Noble have physical bookstores when I can browse and shop. I decided to use Nook because they have a quality product (I love Nook Simple Touch with Glowlight) and they employee people in my community. As far as the Windows 8 Nook app, although it needs improvement it is currently much better than the Kindle app. I hope that by partnering with Microsoft Nook will continue to be a viable alternative to Kindle. Competition and options are good things.

The Bassmonkey
on May 11, 2013

Just as an FYI the Nook app does not appear to be available here in the UK, on either Windows RT or Windows 8.
I tweeted to @Surface to find out what was happening and they said to ask the developer, I'm currently waiting for B&N to get back to me.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use