iPod touch 3G and iPod nano 5G revealed

It’s been a tough couple of weeks for Apple. First the Snow Leopard debacle, and now the 9/9/9 event has been ruined: An iPod case maker has inadvertently revealed two of the devices Apple will debut today, the iPod touch 3G and the iPod nano 5G. (According to CNET, anyway.) Here they are.

iPod touch 3G

iPod nano 5G

Discuss this Article 83

panache1023
on Sep 9, 2009
Paul, What exactly was the "Snow Leopard Debacle"? I'm curious. I haven't heard of any debacles, and I read plenty of MS and Apple blogs.
shark47
on Sep 9, 2009
Wow! Impressive design, especially when compared to the sucky Zune HD. Not one letter has been cut off. What does Microsoft have against the "e"?
panache1023
on Sep 9, 2009
Shark, You're such a douche! No one, at least not I, said that the Zune was "sucky". I said the promotional material looked idiotic. Your ability to read and understand seems to be greatly impaired. This will be the last time I address you and your pathetic posts.
chipwinter
on Sep 9, 2009
As long as Apple keeps the prices above the Zune for the same capacity, there could be an opening here for Microsoft.
panache1023
on Sep 9, 2009
Chipwinter, You have a point. But as long as people refer to MP3 players as "iPods", it's going to be difficult, even with a slightly lower price point.
shark47
on Sep 9, 2009
"You're such a douche!" That means a lot, coming from you. Thank you.
rr0de74@live.com
on Sep 9, 2009
Wow Paul, you are such a wealth of knowledge, showing pictures from case makers?? How did you get such information? Oh wait these kind of photos have been around for at least 60 days from a dozen sources. Glad you caught up....oh wait I get it, this is the Winsupersite, before an Apple product launch FUD attempt. Just like a few days before SL launched we got the Paul T FUD machine in high gear. @chipwinter, the rumors, just like the many, many case rumors are that he iTouch will be cheaper than the Zune HD across the board.
lketchum
on Sep 9, 2009
The Nano 5G looks like the now discontinued Zune 4/8/16 - only the Zune's looked a lot better than this. The UI on the Zune is better/cleaner and the touchpad is significantly better than the click wheel, which and with the Nano's UI look really dated. Badly dated - even Soviet era remote control dated. Never really was able to see it so clearly, but the Nano looks bad and while I am at it, the grid square design of the iPod Touch interface - being square and not round like human fingers are, is looking pretty dated, too. Seems oddly confining and rigid as compared to the Zune HD's very fluid and design, which has depth.
hamiltonstallings
on Sep 9, 2009
Lol. iPod nano 5G is the exact same. So is the touch. Gotta love how Apple brainwashes their consumers to buy the same thing every year.
panache1023
on Sep 9, 2009
hamiltonstallings, Since these may not be official pictures, your comments about the touch and nano 5G being exactly the same may be incorrect..then again, they may be. We'll know soon. The best part about your comment is that you assume just because a new product is released, "their consumers" run out to replace what they have. Do you do that when MS releases a new OS? Just upgrade for no reason other than a new OS came out? Do you throw out your computer and buy a new one when a new processor gets released?! You make no sense...your hatred for everything that isn't MS is like an illness! But do you know what I love more than your assumption that people buy the same thing every year? I love how MS keeps trying their hand in consumer electronics, fails to the tune of billions of dollars, and people like you come on here and deride a company that is successful at something MS can't get right. Now THAT is something I love...it's why I keep coming back here.
lketchum
on Sep 9, 2009
rr0de74 is gonna lose it, man... This thread is going over a 100 posts and Paul's gonna make payroll (his own) again. Relax and have some fun with it. I have to say... Apple's looking mighty dated and long in the tooth with their designs... it's like too much of any "one" food - you may love it, but you get tired of eating it day in, day out, night in, night out... It's like a middle aged person that is not aging well... square, boxy, confining, off-putting... contrasting with a weebles wobble but they don't fall down kind of "roundy" weirdness that is just add... wobble... wobble all over any flat surface.
jipock@acm.org
on Sep 9, 2009
I would NOT want to be an executive for that company that made the iPod cases... Taking the 'lightning' away from Steve Jobs 2nd triumphant return? What usually happens to companies that spoils Steve's surprises?
Mum
on Sep 9, 2009
I think the huge Snow Leopard debacle was when some sites reported that the Snow Leopard install DVD has an old version of Adobe Flash player. Which, at the time the OS went GM, had been old for 8 days. A non-debacle if I've ever seen one.
resplendent
on Sep 9, 2009
The touch homescreen appears to be that of a 1G touch. It's clearly NOT running OS 3.0, so it's a safe bet that picture was at least partially, if not entirely photoshopped. Either way there's about 100 things wrong with it. The nano I have no idea.
xpxp2009
on Sep 9, 2009
What did they reveal? These look exactly the same as the iPhone/iPod Touch has since June 2007. And Paul, are you aware that your sign-up has been broken for at least a year? I finally figured out how to get on here by signing up at Windows IT Pro's website. But the form provided by your link creates accounts that can never be activated.
jipock@acm.org
on Sep 9, 2009
Re: Broken Website Yes, it's broken. From the Podcast, though, I think paul mentioned that it will be getting updated in the near future
subzerohitman721
on Sep 9, 2009
So a few cases and photoshopped images have be leaked. So what? It wasn't Paul or ZDnet that leaked these images. You can thank Cygnett for the leak. Its funny how folks getting mad because of speculation and letting the cat out of the bag early. Isn't this what the press does? Don't they get early copies of speeches and the scoop? It just seems like people rail against Paul or anyone in the Windows/Microsoft world just to sound like angry self righteous person. What did you expect? If he's really that bad, there are plenty of other technology websites on the web. Just move along. No need to sound like you're going to have an aneurysm because some guy on a Windows site leaks information about an Apple product. What does it matter? People will still drool over the new iPods. People will still buy it. Paul will go on doing his thing.
SnakeDoctor
on Sep 9, 2009
@iketchum wipe the Steve Balmer man gravy off your chin brother. You are a crazy Microsoft fangirl. Worse than Mike Galos if that is possible. The Zune to this date is a money pit that is loosing its arrrrse in the market. I hope for you sake the Zune HD does well or you mama may tear down your Bill Gates poster when she is cleaning your room. For the geniuses posting here, these are "Case Photos" and not device photos. I know its really hard to see that, NOT. Case Photos as in cheap third party silicone cases. In both photos its clear as day. The only thing this reveals is the camera on the iTouch. The Nano in these photos could easily be the same as the current photos. Paul you amaze me with your Apple coverage. You are like a 13 year old with this kind of drivel. You are like some jilted lover that tries to stick it to Apple every chance you get. Stick to what you know best, coming out with books that contain 90% of the last book. Is Windows 7 Secrets the biggest ever book to cover a service pack?
Waethorn
on Sep 9, 2009
Oooooh. These are cases. I thought Apple was just making the new gen iPods just look super-cheap (especially the nano). So does the nano actually have a real 16:9 screen this time, or did they fudge it up again like they did the touch/iPhone? They need to kill the shuffle too. What a stinker that one was. Did anybody actually buy one last year? I know that local big box stores near me don't usually have them in stock because they say that they had numerous returns on them, and people usually switch to a non-Apple MP3 player with a colour screen for no more than the same money (sometimes less) and with the same storage space, but with controls that actually make sense to anybody that isn't Steve Jobs.
AlasdairM
on Sep 9, 2009
This isn't news. Ruined? I think not. The first picture is an iPhone with the iPod Touch screen overlaid. You can tell it's an iPhone because it looks substantially thicker, has a chunky chrome bezel and has a vibrate switch on the side. Why on earth would an iPod Touch have a vibrate switch? The second picture just looks like a normal iPod Nano, in a case.
EricoF3
on Sep 9, 2009
@hamiltonstallings: lol right... Noooo! THey changed the apple logo... It is now in color rather than glass like.... This is the change of the nano...
Joe05
on Sep 9, 2009
I'm not sure about these pics, what's with the ear speaker on the full size ipod touch? it looks like they took an iphone and photo shopped it. I also disagree with your snow leopard assessment, Snow Leopard is a big deal from an architecture standpoint, Apple has updated the innards to position OSX for the future, but yeah I think too many Mac fans over hyped it and feel let down. The real benefits of Snow leopard will become more apparent with time and all the complainers will settle down. As an aside, many of these same changes have already been implemented in Vista and further refined in Windows 7 As for the Zune HD, its a very sweet device from my initial impressions , the Zune is packing an awful lot of power for something that's "just" an MP3 media player. If the rumors I've heard are true, this thing is gonna rock...and sign me up for Zune and its services.
mjb5406
on Sep 9, 2009
panache1023, Thurrot thinks anything associated with Apple is a "debacle"... why not? He gets those little perk checks signed by Steve Ballmer of Microsoft, so you can't bite the hand that feeds you. Oh, and to the people saying MS may have a chance, Apple is supposed to announce a 64GB iPod Touch at $379, according to some sources (not yet confirmed, of course), and will being in their 32GB 3rd Gen iPod Touch at the same price as Zune HD.
mjb5406
on Sep 9, 2009
Joe05, There has been a speaker on the iPod Touch since the 2nd Gen. It's only mono, but a speaker.
meason
on Sep 9, 2009
well I have had more broken apps with my Snow Leopard upgrade then I ever did with my Vista upgrade..... How dare apple break my carbonite backup.
hamiltonstallings
on Sep 9, 2009
Hey panache, I'm glad I make you so mad with just one sentence. Are you posting here because you are waiting for your spinning wheel of death to resolve itself?
Ocean
on Sep 9, 2009
Hey Paul, Can we have a post on the Snow Leopard debacle here or on WinInfo Daily News? Thanks, Your Readers
EricoF3
on Sep 9, 2009
Joe05 said: "OSX for the future, but yeah I think too many Mac fans over hyped it and feel let down." hmm! OSX cannot be for the future, it is a OS of the 70's...
panache1023
on Sep 9, 2009
hamiltonstallings, I am far from mad because you make absurd, idiotic comments and "lol" at yourself. I'm posting here because I have a stupid hour glass mouse cursor on Windows XP. What does that mean to you? It's weird that someone like you rags on Apple freaks. You are the prime example of "those in glass houses shouldn't throw stones"
Ocean
on Sep 9, 2009
Paul, Another question: You made a post -> "Amazon has released a version of my latest book, Windows 7 Secrets, for its popular Kindle e-book reader. Buy it today!" Why is the Kindle version $25.19????
EricoF3
on Sep 9, 2009
@meason: This is the strenght of MS ... BACKWARD COMPATIBILITY... So, Hurray for Apple... it reinvent the world... by using an 40 years old unsecure OS kernel as a base for their GUI shell... Hurray...
RobertC
on Sep 9, 2009
Apple has run out of steam on the iPod line. It's simply reduced to replicating the iPhone without the 3G radio. The classic looks staid. The nano has a microscopic click wheel that is impossible to use accurately. The non-Touch interface is dated and lacks features. The shuffle is a piece of crap that nobody knows how to use - it represents simplicity taken to it's extreme illogical conclusion. Basically, Apple has let the iPods wither and die. But they still cash in with minor updates and persistent demand year-in year-out due to pure brand name recognition and mindshare. As Mike Galos said a while back, Apple dropped the ball on innovation when it started using the new colours of the nano as a major feature in advertising.
meason
on Sep 9, 2009
I predict.... A color it yourself nano....... it will be primer white/grey and a new line of iPaints will be released to allow you to paint your new nano with 60 dollar bottle of plastic model paint.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Sep 9, 2009
RobertC "As Mike Galos said a while back, Apple dropped the ball on innovation when it started using the new colours of the nano as a major feature in advertising." To be precise, I was saying that when they used the new colors of the nano as THE major new feature. If it were just one of the new features they pushed that wouldn't have been so sad.
panache1023
on Sep 9, 2009
Just curious now that this "lack of innovation" from Apple has been brought up. Can someone please explain how MS is innovating in the PMP market? Specifically, what about the Zune HD is "innovative"? Thanks.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Sep 9, 2009
panache If you actually want to learn more about the Zune HD, Paul has two articles http://www.winsupersite.com/zune/zunehd_preview.asp http://community.winsupersite.com/blogs/paul/archive/2009/05/28/more-det... You might find them a good source of information. Or you could go to the product page at http://www.zune.net/en-us/mp3players/zunehd/default.htm
Ocean
on Sep 9, 2009
No Mike, how is it innovative. *You* tell us.
mjb5406
on Sep 9, 2009
EricoF3, Your statement shows just how ignorant and uninformed you are... must be beause of all of the malware infecting your Windoze system. OS X blows the doors off Windows for stability.
panache1023
on Sep 9, 2009
MikeGalos, I appreciate the links, but I am just asking a rather simple question. People keep pointing out how Apple is failing to innovate the iPods, so I'm just curious about what is *innovative* in the Zune HD. Honestly, I'm really curious.
PeyloW
on Sep 9, 2009
Do not judge Paul to hard, it will take many posts with repeated talk points to create the illusion of Snow Leopard and new iPods failing. Not all readers are as strong in their faith as Mike Galos and Waethorn anymore. Pretty soon there might even be a need for facts.
beaker
on Sep 9, 2009
is this applerumors.com now? WTF?
daveinla
on Sep 9, 2009
It has to be the first article on the Net judging the Snow Leopard release a "Debacle" ! LOL but what other words can you expect from Paul !! All major release of OSX have been a debacle for him, while Vista's been a hit ... go figure... Well actually it's not so much a hit for him anymore nowadays that there is a new darling to cherish. And daring to post about some new product based on dubious pics from accessory maker... I remember when Paul was blasting some CNET or PCMag writer because they were writing negatively about some MS products they had not even seen or tried at 100 % and he was accusing them of being a caricature of journalist... well welcome to the club !! I just hope you keep your finger crossed until the REAL event for these products to be really revealed otherwise you gonna look like a big fool... which you already look like with your "Debacle" article and your ATT/Apple nonsense mouth-foaming article !!!
Andreas J
on Sep 9, 2009
Lol, the new nano looks like the old zunes ;)
Ocean
on Sep 9, 2009
Somebody google 'Snow leopard Debacle'
Ocean
on Sep 9, 2009
Ok, so know we know that Mike Galos is a coward.
daveinla
on Sep 9, 2009
Ok the new iPods are crap based on the appearance. (which shows iPhone OS1.0 on the pic BTW). Maybe Apple should have given them an ovoid shape in order to be "Innovative" ?? Lol...
lketchum
on Sep 9, 2009
Panache1023, If I may, the interface is truly innovative - as I said earlier, the twist interface, though great on its own, now has this feature/task focus ability that provides large round targets for touch. It's pretty amazing and as a UI is very different and extremely fast. The other area where the HD is truly innovative that comes to immediate mind is what is possible from day one - unfortunately, I can't say any more about that here. I can say that doing really amazing things on the "platform" is going to be very easy and profitable for those that work it. Forget experience integration buzz and think about content fusion and universal access to a very broad universe of content - some from new sources, but as importantly, much from existing ones and then seamlessly mixing and accessing all of it from an equally diverse mix of platforms. Bolt all that to greatly extended social activities already well ahead of the competition and you can see a lot of innovation without even having to begin to talk about what the hardware's potential is. Finally, the deal is great - an all you can eat buffet of "stuff" for three different people, using three different devices on three different computers for one price - it's a great value and saves a lot of money. The Zune HD, its client software, Marketplace, and Social make the entire Zune experience very complete and unique at the same time. Extend that to the Xbox as they have and the PC, as they have and the Zune adds a lot more value outside the device itself.
EricoF3
on Sep 9, 2009
BladRnr said: "@EricoF3 You seriously need to check your spelling, an English lesson or two, and grammar skills." Yes! You are right!! My english spelling is not really well ... Waht is your point by told me that here in that blog?? This is off topic isn't it??
gfryesc1
on Sep 9, 2009
I'd say Microsoft is about to have a bad day, I noticed that Paul didn't mention the ipod price drops also out today. He's very selective about information, you know.
EricoF3
on Sep 9, 2009
mjb5406 said: "EricoF3, Your statement shows just how ignorant and uninformed you are... must be beause of all of the malware infecting your Windoze system. OS X blows the doors off Windows for stability." WRONG!!! The only reason OSX has stability it is because it only run in a highly controlled hardware environmental... In comparition, Windows is 99% stable when running on any hardware that exist in the world... It really easy to pretend OSX is table when it don't run on 95% of the existing hardware....

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use