The New York Times takes on J Allard

Saul Hansell at The New York Times talks to Microsoft's J Allard about the Zune. Here are some choice quotes:

On Zune marketshare: "Fifteen percent [market share] would be great for us," he said. [Microsoft] hopes to displace Sandisk as the second-ranked vendor of MP3 players next year. In North America [last year], Apple had a share of 75 percent in the [hard drive-based MP3 player] category to Microsoft’s 15 percent.

On learning how to enter this market. "The less-than-enthusiastic response to the first generation of Zunes was an important learning experience. I’m a big believer in failing fast … If we skipped last year, we would have never come out with the product we did this year … We learned that because of the shortfalls in the PC client [software], the device was less useful … People hated that there was no podcasts, that they couldn’t fill their cultural cache [the Zune] with the stuff that was meaningful to them."

On DRM: "People are unhappy with DRM download-to-own. If I buy a track with DRM and it has fewer rights than the CD, that is where people get their nose out of joint. There is no art, no track information, no liner notes. I can’t sell it for four bucks to buy a burrito if I’m hungry."

On subscription services: "Music subscription services are very promising. But the music labels have hurt them, imposing too many restrictions ... It is easy to get subscriptions right, if we could reinvent rights. If we had full rights to every piece of music recorded since the beginning of time, and we could choose what to do with it, we could build a dynamite service …. It would be free and available on every device …. There would be advertising. Or it would be a loss leader to a higher value proposition."

On the record industry: "The music industry is very healthy. The record industry is the problem. The notion that the only way to monetize artist creation is 10 songs that come out every 18 months, in a package called an album — the classic record model — isn’t what it used to be. [Musicians can profit from] reality shows. Fashion. Maybe I release five or six tracks and the rest comes in a paid subscription, that is basically a fan club …. Most labels are going to become management companies [making money from booking concerts, etc. rather than selling CDs.] There will be a lot of pain [on the way to that future]."

There's more: J Allard: Microsoft’s Plan to Be King of All Media and J Allard: Dancing Around the Cellphone Question

Discuss this Article 3

cesjr
on Nov 18, 2007
Over on Amazon, the Zune 4GB and 8GB players are not selling well. If you look at the rankings based on sales, the first flash zune is #82 (black 8GB). http://amazon.com/s/ref=sr_pg_4?ie=UTF8&rs=172630&rh=n%3A172282%2Cn%3A10... The hard drive zunes (especially last year's models at giveaway loss-making prices) are doing better. I think this points to the fact that the prototypical Zune customer is a geeky male windows enthusiast or Pc gamer, who are more likely to opt for greater capacity and don't mind the larger form factor. Looks like Zune is going to have a harder time with the more mainstream, less geeky customer buying a smaller capacity flash player. This customer is more likely to go with the herd (whether that be windows when it comes to PCs or the iPod/iTunes when it comes to a portable media player). Another problem is, frankly, portable media players are to some degree about fashion and the flash Zunes look like last year's iPod nano. The flash Zunes also are in fact significantly larger - quite a bit thicker and a lot taller. They just look bigger, while the new iPod nanos seem impossibly small. Smaller usually wins - fits better in a purse or pocket.
cesjr
on Nov 18, 2007
forgot one thing - the flash zunes are priced the same as the iPod nanos - so that's what they really compete against. Sansa and some others have carved out a substantial niche for lower priced players. But the Zunes - at the same price as an iPod nano -- don't compete with those cheaper flash players.
DRWAM
on Nov 18, 2007
The Zunes were selling well at first, but the pre-order price was very discounted, making it appealing. The price now matches iPods, and they look like iPods too. IMO, Microsoft should make a better product and make it cheaper to better compete. This would make a better strategy, and ultimately help the consumer as it would pressure all competition to make better products, cheaper. Just look at plasma and LCD TV's. Well, that's my two cents, and I am better at medicine anyway. Full disclosure, I own 3 Sansa's and 2 iPods [actually, I bought them for the wife and kids, as I don't use them. I just maintain and load them.]

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use