Safari 5. Yeah, You Should Trust the Web To These Guys

Apple has now fixed this, but their original advertising page for Safari 5 didn't display correctly in any browser. Including Apple's. Here's how it looked originally in Safari 4 (Windows). We tested it on the iPad and the iPhone, and it had the same error.

FAIL.

Discuss this Article 16

tomperanteau
on Jun 7, 2010
They need to hire more opensource people to help them.
Waethorn
on Jun 7, 2010
LOL@Apple. See the web in a "W#0!3 N3UU W4Y!" Riiiight. Apple's site is horrible in the #1 browser in use on the planet: IE. They're using some specifically-Safari Webkit-optimized Javascript that causes it to run slowly in other web browsers, and it's brutal in IE. Thing is, how do they figure people will switch from PC to Mac if potential customers can't get to the Apple Store order page in a timely manner? SHOPPING FAIL!
chipwinter
on Jun 7, 2010
That was an awesome catch. Apple must really suck if they had that up on the web for a few minutes.
gavers
on Jun 7, 2010
As a Mac user I really only have three browser choices: Safari, Firefox or Chrome. Sure there are other minor browsers, but I don't the time to test them all so I'll stick with what's popular. Chrome is ugly -- no thanks. Granted, Firefox is ugly too but it can be made to look nice. Firefox has been my default browser for about two years now. But with each release it gets slower and more crash prone (even with flash blocked.) Today I ditched it and I'm giving Safari another chance. I'd actually welcome Internet Explorer on my Mac, I just don't see Microsoft ever doing that. My only complaint with Safari so far is I see no way to block Flash. An ad-blocker would be nice too, but I can live without it given Safari's speed and (hopefully) stability.
whiplash55
on Jun 7, 2010
Someones head will roll over that one.
Killsocket
on Jun 7, 2010

I know you are trying to be funny, and it is, but...

comingupforair.net/.../explorer-fail-thumb.jpg

Looks like Firefox for the win!

clindhartsen
on Jun 7, 2010
Yup, all bow to the great coders in Cupertino. ;) iTunes, Safari, what's to hate when you're a Windows user? I mean, it's only a few screwed up web pages and a program that takes a minute to load...
rr0de74@live.com
on Jun 7, 2010
On my Macbook, Safari 5 seems faster, but Chrome is just better for so many reasons. I tried it out on my Windows 7 Desktop 64bit, and man it was a lot slower than both Chrome and IE8. Lots of disk activity. I even let is sit for a few hours thinking 7 was indexing all of the new files installed. Still slow hours later. Safari before this update was so far behind. It still is in many ways, book mark organizing is down right horrible. @Gravers search on "click2flash" its a popular Safari flash blocker. The reader fuction in the new Safari looks like a blatent rip off of.... http://lab.arc90.com/experiments/readability/ Readability is faster and better, with more options and works on any browser on Windows or Mac. Apple thanks for playing, but he browser game is for the big boys.
Backup77
on Jun 7, 2010
Safari is a dog of a browser on Windows PC's. That page above is just another example, how it went live is another matter.
jeffsters
on Jun 8, 2010
See! Now you see why you need Safari 5? ;-)
Waethorn
on Jun 8, 2010

"Why should Apple deny those of us using capable browsers a cool experience just to accommodate those using a crappy browser."

It's a shopping site.  If you want to attract customers, you do so based on the lowest common denominator, otherwise it's a business process failure, and you lose customers because of an inferior shopping experience.

"I think its acceptable to serve IE a slower experience until MSFT gets its browser act together."

You're obviously not a web developer then.

Did I mention:  it's a bloody shopping site!

It's bad in Firefox, and nearly as bad in Opera too.  Chrome isn't nearly as fast as Safari either, and it uses the same layout engine!

FYI:  Safari 3 and every previous version was a buggy pig, and Apple express-tracked 4 and 5 to try to distance themselves from those versions as quickly as possible.

Waethorn
on Jun 8, 2010

"My only complaint with Safari so far is I see no way to block Flash"

Delete the plugin.

macs.about.com/.../safariplugin.htm

Grannyville
on Jun 8, 2010

I feel like I'm the only Windows and Mac user who still enjoys using Safari on their PC.

Just installed Safari 5 on my Windows PC. Seems very much the same apart from a couple of things.

Just finished watching the Apple keynote that I downloaded through iTunes. Very disappointed with what was announced, apart from iPhone 4. Everything else that was talked about was already done in their previous keynote earlier this year.

yoshipod
on Jun 8, 2010

clindhartsen said:

"Yup, all bow to the great coders in Cupertino. ;)

iTunes, Safari, what's to hate when you're a Windows user? I mean, it's only a few screwed up web pages and a program that takes a minute to load..."

Kind of like how Word, Excel & Powerpoint load & run much faster on Windows than a Mac? Word 2008 takes about 5-10 seconds just for the recent items menu to display on 3.0 Ghz iMac.

My guess is that the Chrome browser will also run faster on the Google's Chrome OS.

Who would have imagined that a company's software runs better on the platform they develop than on a competitors one.

jasonlotito
on Jun 8, 2010

@rr0de74@live.com

"The reader fuction in the new Safari looks like a blatent rip off of...."

It should.  They did use code from Readability.  It's in the credits, and the Readability guys know about it.

Saying it's a blatent ripoff kind of ignores the fact that Readability was licensed to be used in this manner.

Dr. Daniel Jackson
on Jun 8, 2010

"My only complaint with Safari so far is I see no way to block Flash. An ad-blocker would be nice too, but I can live without it given Safari's speed and (hopefully) stability."

I use both of these, and I think they work fine.

http://clicktoflash.com/

code.google.com/.../safariblock

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use