SuperSite Blog Daily Update: December 7, 2010

Good afternoon.

This food poisoning episode might be something else entirely. I'm mostly better, still a bit off, but my daughter was up all night puking her guts out, so she's home today. So I have no idea what this is. The world's fastest-acting stomach flu? Who knows?

--

Despite it's love affair with Apple, I continue to trust Consumer Reports. And this week, it released the results of a survey of almost 60,000 readers regarding smart phones. And the results suggest that the public, at least, has fallen for the "it's all AT&T's fault" with regards to the iPhone's reception problems: AT&T was tied for the worst-rated wireless network in the US, according to those readers. But here's the thing. Since switching from the iPhone to Windows Phone, I've had none of the reception issues on AT&T that used to dog me before. I'm just one person, of course. But my experience suggests that at least part of the blame falls on Apple.

--

Andy Rubin, the "architect" of Google's Android OS for smart phones, had some cute comments about Windows Phone in a recent interview. Some of these comments are either completely clueless or a willful attempt to confuse the reader (i.e. "lie"):

He reserved a fair amount of venom for Microsoft, actually, disagreeing with their design decisions and mentioning that even the ultra-modern Windows Phone 7 is saddled with “this package of stuff that was invented before the Internet.” I suspect there’s plenty of legacy code in Google’s borrowed libraries as well, but that’s neither here nor there.

No offense, but that is both here and there: It's a lie. Windows Phone is not "saddled" by "legacy" code any more than Android is. In fact, the programming environment is based on a much more modern set of libraries--Silverlight and XNA--than is Android, which requires 1990's-era Java experience.

OK, I shouldn't be surprised that the father of Android is putting down Windows Phone--and he did call it a "decent 1.0" product, which sort of refutes the previously quoted comment--but I should point out that he was very complementary to Apple's iPhone. Which is based on OS X. Which is based on Free BSD. Which is based on legacy code that "was invented before the Internet." Sigh.

--

Matthew Miller has a nice overview of the Samsung Galaxy Tab. Looking back on this Dell Inspiron Duo debacle, I see now that I should have just skipped this dog and gone with an Android device. In fact, the Duo is so horrible, I'm going to try and just return it to Dell.

--

Microsoft announced today that Office Web Apps is now available in 15 new countries: China, Denmark, Finland, Hong Kong, Italy, Japan, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, Taiwan, and Turkey. This brings the total number of countries to 26, or "more than one-third of all earthlings," according to Microsoft.

--

Microsoft announced new anti-tracking technologies for IE 9, which will appear in the RC version in "early 2011." I'll have a news story up shortly.

--

Google delayed Chrome OS-based netbooks to the middle of 2011. Again, I'll have  a news story up shortly.

Discuss this Article 7

whiplash55
on Dec 8, 2010
The same scunge is going through our house hold, it was like 4 days of food poisoning.
matt.brown
on Dec 8, 2010
Yeah, I had a similar bug a couple years ago. I thought I had food poisoning after Thanksgiving, but then I heard that it was going around in my family. Tough stuff.
Avro
on Dec 8, 2010
Paul,
I have to disagree with you about AT&T. In the UK we hear from Americans about iPhone problems that we never experience here and we put it down to AT&T problems.


B52
on Dec 8, 2010
Having given up my iPhone 3GS a couple of weeks ago for a Samsung Focus (though I'm still a little grumpy about the weak Zune playlist support for podcasts), I can attest as well to the superiority of Windows Phone 7 overall, but specifically regarding the PHONE itself. I could never make a call from my office with the iPhone, and reception was always weak or nonexistent. It dropped calls incessantly. Not so the Focus. I can use it in my office now without qualms. The tech media is really blowing this story, as they blow so many others.
B52
on Dec 8, 2010
FYI, Avro: My understanding is that the GSM chip (or protocol or frequency, I'm not fact perfect here) used in the States is different than the one used in the UK and Europe, and that Apple made a mistake in the choice of chipset for the US market. I know scores of people on AT&T who use other phones without encountering the problems that iPhone users (like me) experienced.
Avro
on Dec 8, 2010
B52

Yes I know the frequencies are different. I also understand that Americans have to pay for handsets in addition to having a contract. Absolutely Bizarre. Handsets here are usually free with a contract, but about 67% of UK phones are Pay As You Go. You buy the handset and then pay for usage. I think you call them prepay in the US.

nerdshoveler
on Dec 9, 2010
I wouldn't say Consumer Reports has a blind eye to Apple faults, though they are inconsistent in their reporting of the iPhone 4. They have commented, in a couple of their more recent issues, that they can not recommend the iPhone 4 due to it's reception issues. They acknowledged that Apple offers a bumper case, but they still want Apple to not put the responsibility on the user to fix a design flaw. In a Sept 13 blog post, they said "But putting the onus on any owners of a product to obtain a remedy to a design flaw is not acceptable to us. We therefore continue not to recommend the iPhone 4, and to call on Apple to provide a permanent fix for the phone's reception issues."

However, when you go to their website and review their smartphone reviews, the iPhone 4 is still listed as a recommended model.

Blog post can be found at: http://bit.ly/aHcZIb



Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use