SuperSite Blog Daily Update: January 2, 2011

Did Raymond Chen just solve the mystery of the Windows clipboard bug? The one the Windows team couldn't find or fix? I think he did. Thanks to David R. for the link.

*


More silly link-bait: Business Insider coyly asks, Is Google The Next Yahoo? Duh. Obviously not. Google is far more diversified than Yahoo ever was, thanks to its bucketloads of cash and insatiable expansion appetite. They're not even comparable. Obviously.

*


People often wonder what the difference is between journalism and blogging, but I actually think it's pretty clear cut. For example, reporting on the latest Google Doodle? Not journalism, no matter where the story appears. Heck, it's even lazy from a blogging standpoint. In fact, that's sort of how I define it: If it's lazy and lacks even cursory research, it's blogging.

*


And here's a cute intersection of both silly link-bait and non-journalism: The Register (also coyly) asks, iPad's biggest rival? Microsoft's dead Courier. Wrong again, monkey boy. The Courier is a dumb idea, and let's stop pretending otherwise, please. But what the heck, let's spend a second actually answering a semi-rhetorical, completely fanciful, headline-based question: What is the iPad's "biggest rival"? Today, it's the Samsung Galaxy Tab, an Android-based tablet that fixes the size problem of the iPad but then introduces a slew of new problems, all based around the inexplicably inconsistent Android UI. Looking ahead to 2011 and beyond, the iPad's real rivals are, of course, a slew of Android-based tablets, the RIM PlayBook, a handful of Windows 7-based tablets that actually work, and, maybe, just maybe, a generation of ARM-based Windows Embedded tablets. We'll see. But this is such a silly conversation. The Tab is it, today.

*


I like ZD's Christopher Dawson a lot, and he has an interesting taken on Paul Allen's spurious tech industry patent lawsuits. According to the Allen camp, it's all "posturing and process," which pretty much proves my point about using this as an excuse to clean up the US patent system: It's just a waste of time and money. Still not convinced? Allen's camp believes "that a settlement in this case was very likely with Allen walking away with some money." Great. Just what that guy needs. And deserves.

Discuss this Article 3

GoodThings2Life
on Jan 3, 2011
OK, I'll bite... why do you think the Courier project is/was a stupid idea? I'm really curious on your perspective of this one, because as a Tablet PC user I was genuinely interested in the concept (even while reserving judgment until it was beyond vaporware).
pthurrott
on Jan 3, 2011
GT2L ... I have a pet peeve about tech products that mimic the real world, because it's lazy and bad UI. Just because a traditional book "opens up" into a two-page layout doesn't mean that that form factor makes sense for a reading device, let alone a tablet computer. It's just complexity. People can't handle two screens on a PC by and large (the percentage who does this must be low single digits) and they would have trouble with a two screen tablet unless it was seamless (i.e. looked like a single screen when open, with no border) and worked like a single screen. Asking people to drag and drop between screens sounds silly when you remember that the vast majority of PC users can't even handle more than one app at a time. This, among other reasons, points the way towards why the iPad usage model makes the most sense for most people, and why Apple is going that route, at least optionally, with full-screen apps in Mac OS X as well.
GoodThings2Life
on Jan 3, 2011
Those are all very good points. I'm certainly an except to your rule and function very well on two monitors at my desktop, but I definitely agree with you on the "average consumer" point of view. Since you bring it up, there is also a technological complexity there with connecting wires and hinges that let's face it-- people could break quite easily. As for multitasking, you're definitely right. I can only think of a handful of users who efficiently multitask, and I know several of my coworkers who can't grasp the concept of minimize/restore to save their life.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use