SuperSite Blog Daily Update: November 10, 2010

Good morning.

It looks like RIM is going to try and undercut iPad pricing with its upcoming BlackBerry PlayBook. This is very wise: The iPad is overpriced, and thanks to this pricing, the competing tablets coming from the Android world and elsewhere are coming in too high as well. Note, too, that the PlayBook as a 7-inch screen, which is far more desirable than the too-large iPad, though I still don't give RIM much of a chance here.

--

Speaking of the iPad, I've got iOS 4.2 installed on my own iPad, and I don't quite see what the fuss is all about. In fact, I don't see anything major here other than the addition of the Xbox LIVE rip-off Game Center and annoying change to the screen rotation lock so that it's now not a screen rotation lock but is rather a mute button. What??

Anyway, looking back to Apple's FUD-tastic September pre-announcement about iOS 4.2, which was made before it released iOS 4.1, we can see that one of the company's number one promised feature for this release is wireless printing support through AirPrint. Which, from what I can tell, is nowhere to be found in the actual software. Turns out it may have been cancelled. Maybe they'll get to it in iOS 4.3. Heck, at least multitasking works.

--

By the way, it's hard to look at the Samsung Galaxy Tab and not notice that the form factor is almost identical to that of the Windows Phone-based Samsung Focus, with the same curved, tapered ends. Take the next logical step and it's hard not to imagine a Windows Phone-based Galaxy Tab. That's the tablet I want.

--

I was able to test that new RockMelt browser yesterday and it's pretty much what I thought it would be: An ugly and pointless version of Chrome. This thing will go nowhere, and I'm done with it. And can we please stop pretending Marc Andreessen is some kind of genius.

--

I'll be appearing on What The Tech tonight at 7pm ET if you're interested. I think the primary topic will be Windows Phone 7, but I'm sure we'll get some Black Ops talk in as well. :)

Discuss this Article 13

meason
on Nov 10, 2010

I guess printing is hard for apple......

I have an iPad, I use it a lot, and I like it.  Used mainly as an email/web browsing machine with some games.  

I have an iPod Touch with game center etc... the only useful feature I see in it for my iPad is the folders and even that is limited in that I can only put so many items in each folder (i.e. I have two games folders)

I have not seen a single game on game center worth buying when I have looked.  

I plan on dumping the iPod once I see the microSD issues with the Focus worked out.

jetsafl
on Nov 10, 2010
"Take the next logical step and it's hard not to imagine a Windows Phone-based Galaxy Tab. That's the tablet I want." -- Couldn't agree more, I wish Microsoft would think this way too, but they seem stuck on the idea of Windows 7 Tablets only.
bill@bleeman.com
on Nov 10, 2010
While I haven't been chomping at the bit for the 4.2 update, the one thing I was looking forward to was the ability to have more than one Exchange account. I realize you primarily use Gmail, but wondered if you could tell if that feature was included?
chuckb84
on Nov 10, 2010

"The iPad is overpriced, and thanks to this pricing, the competing tablets coming from the Android world and elsewhere are coming in too high as well. Note, too, that the PlayBook as a 7-inch screen, which is far more desirable than the too-large iPad,"

Two very questionable statements. The iPad actually undercuts the current crop of competing tablets as I noted on your blog yesterday. Are you really claiming that Apple's iPad pricing determines Android pricing? Then why would RIM be any different.

Second, we need a marketplace reaction, not just your opinion, as to whether a 7" size is preferable to a 10" size.

Note that is practically impossible for Microsoft to implement ANY tablet if they stick to Windows as the OS and a 7" size, as you suggest.

Let's see what the customers think before jumping to conclusions on what size tablet is best for most people.

MLomasIcomm
on Nov 10, 2010
The Airprint story already seems to be debunked.
Backup77
on Nov 10, 2010
The iOS 4.2 update sounds underwhelming and probably hasn't added much at all in terms of new features. I agree with your comments Paul on the RockMelt browser, it all seems a bit meaningless and unnecessary despite various blogs spruiking its features.
ModernDislocation
on Nov 10, 2010
AirPrint is there. What got canned was printing to a printer that is being shared by a Mac or Windows system. The printer has to be a wireless printer that doesn't an additional device to act as the print server.
samkass
on Nov 10, 2010
How can anything that is selling as fast as it can be made "overpriced"? Doesn't the laws of supply and demand dictate that the iPad is appropriately priced if they couldn't sell more at a lower price?
SPiotr
on Nov 10, 2010
" iPad pricing starts at $499. That’s actually quite aggressive for Apple. In fact, that’s pretty amazing. So good for them. " Paul Thurrott, January 27 2010
wlow3
on Nov 10, 2010
BlackBerry pricing starts below $500? I was guessing $999 to start. That's actually quite aggressive for Blackberry. In fact, that's pretty amazing. So good for them. You sure can reliably peg the iPad pricing though. Whoa! I'd sure like to see someone prove otherwise.
Dipsh t Admin
on Nov 12, 2010
Until they reveal what they mean by "under $500" we really can't say anything yet. $399-449 would be enough of an undercut to perceive it as being "under $500" to make that claim. "How do they price something that has half the screen size at the same price and expect to compete?" 9.7 / 2 = 4.85, the PlayBook is 7.
pthurrott
on Nov 12, 2010
There have been some hilarious comments in here about "doing 10 seconds of research" regarding AirPrint in iOS 4.2. That's good stuff, and if you wrote such a thing, it's time for a long look in the mirror. Two points. I wrote "may have been canceled," not "was canceled." And I got this information from "Cult of Mac," which later had to write a new post explaining that the feature was (probably) still in there. I assume the morons who wrote in about this were also badgering that Mac-idolatry site as well. No? Really? Huh. Here are the links: It's out. http://www.cultofmac.com/apple-may-have-neutered-airprint-for-ios-4-2-re... Oh wait, it's not out. http://www.cultofmac.com/steve-jobs-airprint-has-not-been-pulled-from-io... I assume Gruber's Goobers will, as always, attack them for reporting something different when confronted with new information. After all, in this anti-intellectual world we now live in, that's how to make yourself look smart. Or something. And while we're on the topic, Cult of Mac is now also reporting that AirPlay might be gone from the iPhone. Go get 'em, Apple-tards. Or do you not turn on your own? http://www.cultofmac.com/apple-may-have-removed-airplay-for-the-iphone-3... That's what I thought.
jecouch66
on Nov 12, 2010

@SPoitr '" iPad pricing starts at $499. That’s actually quite aggressive for Apple. In fact, that’s pretty amazing. So good for them. "

Paul Thurrott,  January 27 2010'

You quote out of context to make it seem his previous statement is in contradiction to his current one.  Paul's point in the Jan article was that for Apple it was amazing; not that it was inexpensive for what it is.  Later in that same article, he says "Without being able to touch one ... eh. It seems like a high priced, unnecessary trinket to me.".  Clearly consistent with what he said today and what he's said before.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use