Windows 7 Beta Network Performance

David Travis posts some interesting Windows 7 network file copy performance results. You may recall that I had noticed some issues with network file copies myself, and Microsoft was curious about this. In my case, the copies were all to Windows Home Server, which is based on Windows Server 2003. And sure enough, David expresses surprise about how poorly Windows 7 works with this server version as well.

One of my major complaints about Vista has been the network performance problems, or at least what seemed to be network performance problems. I worked with a couple of guys at work on testing network performance with XP, Vista and Windows 7 Beta.

I used a Windows 2003 Server and a Windows 2008 Server for testing.

I was shocked by the performance of Windows 7 downloading from Windows 2003 server. I hope that Microsoft works on this. Remember that this is a Beta and we will have to wait until RTM to determine the real performance. I am very impressed with the performance of Windows 7 and Windows 2008 server. Hopefully this does not change in the RTM.

Check out the full post for details on the test script and the full results chart.

Discuss this Article 68

RaaJ
on Jan 14, 2009
On a related but probably OT note, I have been having problems with exiting applications in Win7 beta, particularly with a network based file open in the application. Happened to me quite a few times in the last few days with Explorer, Excel 2007, Word 2007 and Outlook 2007. There's something fishy or wonky in the network code, I guess, that, maybe, does not release the file op-lock gracefully. Exiting Outlook 2007 frequently causes a data file check upon launching Outlook again. It'd be interesting to see over the next few weeks what seems to be borked on the network stack side.
xtreem0
on Jan 14, 2009
My main problem with win7 (now that the taskbar has been resolved with that middle button click) is that zune 64bit software crashes on installation... Im hoping it gets fixed though it could just be me.
xtreem0
on Jan 14, 2009
My main problem with win7 (now that the taskbar has been resolved with that middle button click) is that zune 64bit software crashes on installation... Im hoping it gets fixed though it could just be me.
Angel Of Death
on Jan 14, 2009
OK, so this is waaay off topic, but I have to get it out somewhere, and by no means near, this is the closest to the subject as I can get. In M3 the handwriting recognition for Swedish language on tablet PC finally worked. M$ Sweden has promised this functionality for sooo long, first it was in Vista, then in Vista SP1 and now in 7. It is a very strange business approach *not* to get this available. In Sweden all students (yes all - those who don't have opted out for whatever reason, availability is not the issue) and WiFi, 3G and broadband is everywhere. I'm constantly on line one way or the other. Many students go for Mac, because, really it is cooler, but if they would have had the option of making notes on a Tablet, I'm pretty sure that market would rise, with Windows sales (torrent downloads?) going up. Being a researcher myself, I know I long for handwriting recognition in my own language. Anyway, back to the issue. As I said, in M3 Swedish handwriting recognition was finally available. You won't believe my joy. But alas, in the Beta, Swedish language handwriting recognition is not there. What the...?! They take functionality *away* in the "function complete" version? What does it mean? That it will not be there in the RTM? I get screwed again? I'm so frustrated! Sorry but I have to ask you guys. Good luck asking *Microsoft*... I had so hoped that my first post would be a positive one. But I may add that I had all sorts of issues with wireless networking (I have a domain server, WHS, numerous clients, the whole shabam) on M3. The wireless network card would die without any warning, requiring a reboot, network connection would drop for no apparent reason, singal strenght was flaky. So on the same machine with same hardware (the Acer TM C210) and 7Beta, I have still to encounter the same issues. Was probably a driver thing. In M3 I had to install some drivers, but with Beta all is up and running without me having to install a single one. Look! Something positive after all! BTW: I'm all 32 Bit - for whatever reason. Cheers!
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 14, 2009
Angel of Death The current beta has only limited amounts of localization in it. That's fairly typical of betas as localizing is ideally done toward the end of the project when text is locked down and they don't have to translate multiple times. As an example, those of us running Ultimate get the multilanguge user interface and all the language packs as part of the Ultimate version but in the beta that's not included. I'd be very surprised if it wasn't available at the time of the Swedish version.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 14, 2009
Angel of Death btw: I had the same wireless problems for a while and it turned out to be a buggy driver that was fixed by a driver update. I'd guess that there's something in a specific chipset that was fixed by my OEM's updated Vista driver but that wasn't fixed in the Acer driver until they did the Windows 7 version.
Angel Of Death
on Jan 14, 2009
So that does mean that functionality available in the M3 build has been locked down? And probably no way of unlocking. I mean I know it's there, because I was able to write in Swedish in M3. Means I have to wait until RTM in Swedish alternatively go back to M3? Bummer! But really? How am I supposed to beta test this. I mean honestly, they are not planning on releasing that piece of functionality (quite crucial it's right from start I'd say) without beta testing, are they?
realtestman
on Jan 14, 2009
Raaj, I would say it's nothing to do with network performance, but Outlook 2007 itself, as I suffer from the same problem on XP SP3 and a local copy of the PST file. This despite the fact that Outlook 2007 was the one which closed the file itself when I closed Outlook 2007 (and yes I made sure the process quit too).
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 14, 2009
A of D Probably. The best shot for testing is to contact the Swedish subsidiary who will almost certainly run a limited access beta of localized functionality before the localized version gets shipped. The Microsoft AB contact info is: Microsoft AB Box 27 S-164 93 Kista SWEDEN Phone: +46 8 7525600 Fax: +46 8 7505158 Microsoft Customer Care Center: +46 8 752 56 30
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 14, 2009
OT: But Breaking... This is a copy of the mail Steve Jobs posted to Apple employees this afternoon: =========================== Team, I am sure all of you saw my letter last week sharing something very personal with the Apple community. Unfortunately, the curiosity over my personal health continues to be a distraction not only for me and my family, but everyone else at Apple as well. In addition, during the past week I have learned that my health-related issues are more complex than I originally thought. In order to take myself out of the limelight and focus on my health, and to allow everyone at Apple to focus on delivering extraordinary products, I have decided to take a medical leave of absence until the end of June. I have asked Tim Cook to be responsible for Apple’s day to day operations, and I know he and the rest of the executive management team will do a great job. As CEO, I plan to remain involved in major strategic decisions while I am out. Our board of directors fully supports this plan. I look forward to seeing all of you this summer. Steve
robertsjoe
on Jan 14, 2009
After the fiasco that was file copy in Vista I, will Microsoft finally get file copy right? You'd think they would after all these years of writing operating systems.
gorath
on Jan 14, 2009
Mike, that's some pretty serious news about Steve Jobs. I hope he has a speedy recovery from whatever it is.
Waethorn
on Jan 14, 2009
Comparing Windows Server 2003 to Windows Server 2008 isn't accurate. Windows Vista is slower when copying files from Windows Server 2003. That won't likely change much in Windows 7. It may have something to do with NAP or IPv.6 support in Windows Server 2008, I dunno - it's just very different. http://msmvps.com/blogs/bradley/archive/2008/04/29/unscientific-but-wow....
Waethorn
on Jan 14, 2009
How much do you wanna bet that he's undergoing cancer treatments again?
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 14, 2009
Waethorn I'd hate to speculate but I'd guess that Apple's PR people are wording things the same way they have in the past - accurately but taking the most positive prognosis. When asked about a recurrance of his cancer earlier they said, quite clearly, that it had not returned. Since they said it was a hormone problem it's probably a very safe bet that's the case. That their reports on how serious it is are increasing is also not a surprise as they learn more. If you start with the best case prognosis, as you learn more it can only either stay the same or get worse. As such the worsening of the statements doesn't necessarily mean any change in the condition just that they've ruled out some of the more optimistic scenarios. Again, here's hoping he has a speedy and full recovery.
tayme
on Jan 14, 2009
I agree with the wishes for Jobs' speedy and full recovery. With that said, I find the fascination with him similar to that of Obama (actually, I guess it should be vice-versa, since Jobs has been in the spotlight for much longer). Even people like mikegalos and Waethorn seem to be obsessing on the guy's health. --tayme
shark47
on Jan 14, 2009
"After the fiasco that was file copy in Vista I, will Microsoft finally get file copy right? You'd think they would after all these years of writing operating systems." For once, I agree with robertsjoe. "With that said, I find the fascination with him similar to that of Obama (actually, I guess it should be vice-versa, since Jobs has been in the spotlight for much longer). " I think it's his own doing. Daniel Lyons had an article in the latest issue of Newsweek about how Bill Gates "knew how to exit gracefully", while Steve Jobs is a "petulant narcissist with a grandiose sense of his importance and a sadly limited view of the world around him." According to him, Jobs is "clinging on to his CEO job."
tayme
on Jan 14, 2009
@sharky - Like I said...just like Obama! ;-) <-- Kinda winking --tayme
yipcanjo
on Jan 14, 2009
Xtreem0 -- I'm running Win7 64-bit w/ the 64-bit Zune software. Installed/runs perfectly. Not sure where you should start looking on that. Anyone else have issues with Win7 *not* mapping network drives via a login .bat file? Our corp network shares are mapped at login, but it never takes place with Windows7. They map fine if I run the file manually. Is this a UAC issue, perhaps? Vista had this issue too, if I remember correctly, and required a reg hack to fix. Thoughts?
gorath
on Jan 14, 2009
yipcanjo, I've not had any problems getting our vista machines to map network drives using a login .bat script, on either 32 or 64 bit. Never had to hack the registry either.
yipcanjo
on Jan 14, 2009
Well... I should've remembered this, but it is a known issue with UAC and login bat files... http://support.microsoft.com/kb/937624 That said, I just created the EnableLinkedConnections entry and it's all good! Disabling UAC works as well, but I like to leave that going :)
Ocean
on Jan 14, 2009
Microsoft SongSmith: A Fail to Remember The epic fail of the video and the product bring to mind one of the better movie pans of 2008, a scorcher in The New York Times of Mike Myers' "The Love Guru." "A whole new vocabulary seems to be required," critic A.O. Scott wrote, searching for the words to capture his horror. http://blog.newsweek.com/blogs/americangeek/archive/2009/01/14/microsoft...
tayme
on Jan 14, 2009
@Ocean - That article is a good example of the press' bias against Microsoft and for Apple...again, it reminds me of the love affair that the media has with Barack Obama. If you saw the CBS Evening News tonight you could watch Katie Couric swooning over Obama. She looked like she wanted to drop to her knees and...well, you know. Its pretty funny, really. --tayme
shark47
on Jan 14, 2009
One would think Ocean and robertsjoe would get along like a house on fire. It's a shame, really. "That article is a good example of the press' bias against Microsoft and for Apple...again, it reminds me of the love affair that the media has with Barack Obama." Ooh, I felt this thrill going up my leg when I watched Obama on that show. :)
robertsjoe
on Jan 14, 2009
@tayme: "That article is a good example of the press' bias against Microsoft and for Apple.." If Microsoft created something truly exciting, cool and interesting, then the press would care. They don't. Now you know why.
robertsjoe
on Jan 14, 2009
@tayme: So you're saying that Apple is like Obama. Microsoft is G.W. Bush. Makes sense. Cool, interesting and visionary is Apple/Obama. Lame, dumb and evil is Microsoft/Bush. You're right.
Ocean
on Jan 14, 2009
>>That article is a good example of the press' bias against Microsoft and for Apple...<< It's just one blogger...though I'll note that that the web has generally panned the product. I thought it looked interesting when I watched the advert though. >>She looked like she wanted to drop to her knees and...well, you know.<< No, I don't. Tell me.
Ocean
on Jan 14, 2009
>>If Microsoft created something truly exciting, cool and interesting, then the press would care.<< The press cares about Windows 7. Paul calling Steve Jobs a liar in 3, 2, 1....
Ocean
on Jan 14, 2009
Preempting Thurrott: >>A spokesman for the Securities and Exchange Commission, John J. Nester, declined to comment on Apple’s situation. But he said that in general, while there were no specific requirements for companies to disclose the health of their officers or directors, companies needed to assess whether health problems could have a material impact on results.<<
Ocean
on Jan 14, 2009
So who is right and who is wrong: >>"We believe that during Jobs' absence, Apple's sales will be unaffected," analyst Gene Munster told clients in a memo reacting to this afternoon's announcement that Jobs has elected to take a medical leave of absence from his day-to-day leadership role at the Cupertino-based company through June. "More importantly, we believe the pace of innovation will remain solid, driven by key product-minded executives," he continued. "From an operational perspective, we expect [chief operating officer Tim] Cook to maintain the same standard of excellence that he demands as COO."<< or >>the essence of Steve Jobs — the obsessive visionary who involves himself in the smallest details of Apple’s products and advertising — has fostered what is in effect a corporate operating system that will need to be completely upgraded whenever a successor is named. After all, however talented the executives at Apple, one skill they all need is an understanding of how to work with, and when appropriate, defer to, the whims of Steve Jobs. << (NYtimes tech blogger)
abhinov.k.s
on Jan 14, 2009
Just a thought. Isn't the following mentioned specifically in the Windows 7 beta EULA? You may not • disclose the results of any benchmark tests of the software to any third party without Microsoft’s prior written approval
lotsamystuff
on Jan 14, 2009
"How much do you wanna bet that he's undergoing cancer treatments again?" How much you wanna bet "waethorn" just can't help being an obnoxious pr1ck?
subzerohitman721
on Jan 14, 2009
First and foremost, my thoughts and prayers to Steve Jobs and his entire family. Going through health issues is close to my heart because my father has gone through a brain surgery before and my grandmother has heart issues. So please, for the love of all things, this issue with Jobs is about a man dealing with his life and his family. Lets be respectful and take the bickering out of this situation. I hope Steve Jobs recovers quickly and will be around for a very long time. His passion for the business and the industry cannot be denyed and he's someone who has had a tremendous impact. Lets hope we can keep that genius in the world. Heaven only knows we need that kind of genius around. Back to the topic at hand, network filecopy. I have to disagree with the sentiment of the article. Windows 7 has shown significant improvement in network copying. The improvements are there. Pulling programs from the net has been painless and a lot quicker, even over my DSL line. Even pulling files from my Windows Vista notebook is quicker.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 14, 2009
lotsa "How much you wanna bet "waethorn" just can't help being an obnoxious pr1ck?" Considering that you used the news about Jobs as an opportunity to launch an ad hominem attack against me, you are absolutely the last person who can talk about people's comments on Jobs' health.
Lindy
on Jan 14, 2009
Network copy speed the #1 reason I ditched Vista and went to a Mac. In 2007 I was doing a consulting gig that had me on the road visiting various locations. Specifically Exchange installations at the time into branch offices. Anyhow one day using my new notebook, I put the Exchange CD contents into a folder on my HP notebook running Vista pre SP1 (August 2007?) at the time. The copy from CD was quick I think, as I probably walked away. I had built a new 2003 server out at a location the day before. My intent was to pop into the office and copy the folder to the new server, then install Exchange remotely later that night or the next day. I get to the office, jump on the LAN and start the copy, roughly 600meg, about 5000 files. Vista told me it was going to take 4 hours. So began my quest to fix the problem that led me (days later and many crazy hacks) to a MS technet forum filled with 500+ posts about the problem. I gave up. It seems they have not fixed it yet if Windows 7 is still having it. This problem has been around since beta 2 of Vista. XP and OS X blow away Vista and I guess 7 when copying files to a Windows 2003 server. Its a show stopper flat out. Windows 2008 is great but swapping out perfectly running Windows 2003 servers is only going to happen when the hardware is getting old. Old link on the problem. http://dotnet.org.za/codingsanity/archive/2007/07/21/197731.aspx "Copying is so pathetically slow for anything large that in some cases, it's actually easier and faster and less frustrating for me to boot up a VPC containing Windows XP, share the appropriate folders on each Vista machine and use the XP to move the files from the one machine to the other" Peace and prayers to Jobs as well. If its his time to take leave of us, may the Lord be at his side.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 14, 2009
abhinov.k.s. "Just a thought. Isn't the following mentioned specifically in the Windows 7 beta EULA? You may not disclose the results of any benchmark tests of the software to any third party without Microsoft’s prior written approval" Of course. And, unfortunately, it's often ignored. Which leads to companies not including as much monitoring code in betas. Which leads to less effective betas. Which leads to less well tested products. Which leads to worse products. But, it gets the unscrupulous writer more hits on their page. Of course, we're at such a low point in industry "journalism" that I've even seen one relatively well known blogger post how he should be sent early information from companies under embargo and then ignore the embargo because he shouldn't have to live under anyone's terms but his own. And paint the companies' as the bad guys for expecting him to honor his agreements.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 14, 2009
And speaking of the state of computer industry "Journalism", it's now being reported that Dan Lyons (best known for writing the Fake Steve Jobs blog) has been banned from CNBC for an exchange where he criticized CNBC's bureau chief for not admitting to his viewers that Apple had lied to him and manipulated him into writing false stories for them. The following is the beginning of Lyons' comments that got him banned: =============== In my mind Apple never had much credibility. Anybody who's covered them... In my mind there's two kinds of reporters who cover Apple. The kind who realize they're getting snowed and they're getting bullied and they're getting blocked out and realize that a lot of what they're being told is not true and the other kind who suck up in order to get access and end up getting played and punked like your Valley bureau chief has been played and punked by Apple. Steve "Fake Steve Jobs" Lyons - CNBC - 14 January 2009 =============== Video of the exchange at Gizmodo at http://i.gizmodo.com/5131629/fakemodo-cnbcs-jim-goldmans-apple-sources-r...
robertsjoe
on Jan 14, 2009
Great to see Hotmale losing users and GMail growing so fast. "Gmail grew 43 percent last year to 29.6 million. In contrast, the much more massive Yahoo Mail grew 11 percent to 91.9 million uniques. AOL Mail finished in second place for the year with 46.6 million uniques (plus another 7.2 million visitors to AIM Mail), while Hotmail actually declined 5 percent to 43.5 million." http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/01/14/gmail-grew-43-percent-last-year-aol...
DRWAM
on Jan 15, 2009
This is a beta, so it ain't finished. There's obviously more to come. Hopefully SJ will be around to see it. He could easily have serious malabsorbtion problems or have developed an afferent loop syndrome. Somebody tell him to eat some friggin meat! How bout a pepperoni pizza for g's sake! Hope he gets better. If not, I hope the secrecy and lack of beta testing gets laid to rest too, but I mention him [and Bill G in my prayers for the sick every day]. I threw in Bill to be fair, especially since his foundation does so much for the world. Oh, and I would like Live Mobile for my iPhone:).
Waethorn
on Jan 15, 2009
"I get to the office, jump on the LAN and start the copy, roughly 600meg, about 5000 files. Vista told me it was going to take 4 hours." I call it like I see it: bullsh*t (or incompetent IT - take your pick). I'ved used Vista RTM at pre-consumer launch with Small Business Server 2003 R2 (based on Windows Server 2003 no less). My data loadout consists of ~30GB, which needed to be copied to my notebook at the time (a Core [1] Duo 1.6GHz with WiFi-G) as an offline folder sync. It took all of about 20 minutes to complete after connecting the system to the domain. @mike: Survival rates of pancreatic cancer are slim to nil in the long term. If someone actually had pancreatic cancer for this many years, they'd come out of cancer treatments looking like Skeletor in a beatnik costume: witness Steve Jobs at last years WWDC....Then a no-show at this years Macworld....Put 2 & 2 together. A hormonal imbalance can be easy treated by medication. 6 months off isn't justified for that. If it were chemo treatments, you could be looking at 3 months off and maybe another 3 for recovery for good measure. Of course, if he came back to work bald, you know damn well that someone would leak it to either shareholders and/or the public, and Apple can't afford to lose stock value at this point in time (nobody can). Apple is just reporting this as PR fluff for shareholders to keep them at least partially satisfied. If Apple reported the truth, it would come down a lot harder on them. They'll just play a "wait and see" until later this year when the economy should be recovering, otherwise if they took a downfall now, they wouldn't come out of the gutter. There are no consumers right now that want to buy a $3000 laptop.
lotsamystuff
on Jan 15, 2009
"Considering that you used the news about Jobs as an opportunity to launch an ad hominem attack against me" It was a question, not an "attack". If I were to point out that only a thin-skinned passive-aggressive jerk could see it otherwise, you could fairly interpret THAT as an "attack".
Lindy
on Jan 15, 2009
Your funny Waethorn. How could someone be incompetent it was a copy and past to a mapped drive?? I never finished the copy I aborted used a USB stick and moved the files to it, then plugged it into a server. It could have only taken an hour. Also this issues is very widely known and discussed all over the place. Maybe your such a complete blind tool that you never saw it or did but you MS colored goggles shielded you from it. Here is that technet forum with 692 posts about the problem. Many calling MS out with please to fix the problem. The last post was on 1/9/09 and the first was 1/2/07. A lot of incompetent IT people out there! http://social.technet.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/itprovistadesktopui/thr... Like I said I guess the problem has not been fixed hence this thread.
lotsamystuff
on Jan 15, 2009
"A hormonal imbalance can be easy treated by medication." Thank you "Doctor waethorn". Coming from someone who can't even fix a computer without "helper cat", this is particularly egregious. "If someone actually had pancreatic cancer for this many years, they'd come out of cancer treatments looking like Skeletor in a beatnik costume" You really are a twat, aren't you?
deepfry
on Jan 15, 2009
I found that Vista was a little slower than xp when copying large files to a 2003 Server, but not horrendously slow. I don't know if I will get the chance to do that same test with the Windows 7 beta though. Still, as the comments to the original article indicate, you should be using robocopy anyways. It would be interesting to see the results of the same script but using robocopy instead of copy.
lotsamystuff
on Jan 15, 2009
"The following is the beginning of Lyons' comments that got him banned" CNBC says Lyons has NOT been banned. http://news.cnet.com/8301-13577_3-10143316-36.html
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 15, 2009
Lotsa "It was a question, not an "attack". " This isn't some wierd variety of "Jeopardy" where framing an ad hominem attack in the form of a question changes it from being an attack. As I said before when you used the news of Steve Jobs' illness as an excuse for ad hominem attack, you're not exactly a class act, are you? Note that was a question so it wasn't an "attack".
Waethorn
on Jan 15, 2009
"You really are a twat, aren't you?" With you, there is no surprise.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 15, 2009
Waethorn Remember, Lotsa phrased his attack in the form of a question so in his bizarro-Jeopardy world, it's not an attack.
RaaJ
on Jan 15, 2009
I have found that the file transfers on Vista are only marginally slower than XP, and in fact, our company published a paper that showed Vista file transfers were faster with Windows Server 2K8, compared to XP with Windows Server 2003. In many cases, the users are fooled into thinking that the transfer operation has not even started for several minutes while Vista says it is calculating the estimated time to complete the operation. In reality, the file transfer is already under way, and is being continually updated in the background while the GUI displays the progress so far. Many times, when the GUI displayed that a transfer would take a couple of hours, it updates itself to a more reasonable estimate a few minutes later. I guess many people do not observe the transfer all the way through and just abort when it displays a large time estimate to complete the transfer.
mikegalos@msn.com
on Jan 15, 2009
Gizmodo is now reporting that Jim Goldman, the CNBC Silicon Valley bureau chief that Dan Lyons said was punked by Apple has done a 180. http://i.gizmodo.com/5131629/fakemodo-cnbcs-jim-goldmans-apple-sources-r... From reading Goldman's latest column, it looks like he's changed from being in the 2nd group of reporters covering Apple - what Dan Lyons referred to as "the other kind who suck up in order to get access and end up getting played and punked" and is now in Lyons' 1st category, "the kind who realize they're getting snowed and they're getting bullied and they're getting blocked out and realize that a lot of what they're being told is not true " That's a least a little step in the right direction for press coverage.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use