Glad to see you reviewing this. I will follow your writeups with interest.
One really (really!) sensitive Apple fan actually liked it (he also liked Pauls Azure post a lot (unlinked)):
"Microsoft is pitching Windows 8 tablets as the natural rival for the iPad;...
Is it great because it will sell telephones, or is it great because it does an excellent job of poking fun at someone?
The market is expanding. Apples iPad sales went up.
I would argue that "taken from iPad" is incorrect because the presence of Windows tablets did not make Apples sales flatten or recede....