Going Pro: Trouble in Paradise

A tale of compulsion and technical glitches

Greetings from Cancun. Today’s trip to Mexico was an interesting chance to try Surface Pro in the cramped confines of a coach flight, and it performed like a champ. But two strange technical glitches ended up putting the day in the defeat column, though only one of them was Surface Pro related.

To step back a bit, yesterday I mentioned in Going Pro: When Push Comes to Shove that my preference for the larger keyboards I use at home and with my normal Ultrabook, a 15-inch Samsung Series 9, was getting me a bit skittish about relying solely on Surface Pro—with its small Type Cover keyboard and tiny 10.6-inch screen—while on this trip.

What can I say, I’m compulsive. And while this is something I openly confront in many ways—getting rid of physical “things” like books and moving to the cloud as I’ve written about in the “Zero Data” series is one obvious example—it’s also something that is hard to overcome. I suspect it’s an issue with many technical people.

In this case, my compulsiveness actually paid off, however. What I ended up bringing along was way over the top, machine-wise, but remember that I am in the middle of writing about a couple of topics—for this series, the Xbox Music Book and Windows Phone Book, and others—that pretty much necessitate multiple PCs. (Yes, I’m making excuses here. Let’s move on.)

So I did bring the Surface Pro, of course, but also the Surface RT—which I use for Xbox Music Book screenshots and, on this trip, a few rented movies—and my Ultrabook. My carry-on backpack was thus as heavy as a cinderblock. It’s all in the name of science.

On the flight, which left Boston at roughly 7 am, I used the Surface Pro to write and to watch a few movies. The device lasted the entire flight—it was about 4.5 hours in the air—and then some, as I started on it before we took off. As you can see from this admittedly terrible photo (I didn’t want to set off the flash in-flight), Surface Pro is an ideal size for a typical airplane seat-back tray, and working on the flight was just fine.

So that’s the good news.

My first glitch, which isn’t related to the Surface Pro at all, occurred part-way through the flight. I’m not even sure why I did it, but at some point I tapped the power button on my smart phone, an HTC Windows Phone 8X, and nothing happened. So I tapped it again. Nothing. So I held down the power button for 5-6 seconds, waited a few more seconds, and then turned it on again. Obviously, it had frozen for some reason.

When it rebooted, however, the HTC 8X battery gauge was almost empty. I have no idea what caused this, or how that could have happened, but since I had the Surface RT with me as well, I connected the phone to that device via a USB cable and let it charge for the rest of the flight. It was enough to get me past 3pm, when we could finally check-in at the hotel. (We arrived there around noon.)

The second glitch is still unresolved. And concerning.

When we finally did check-in, of course the first thing I did was set up my devices to charge. I always bring a travel-sized power strip with me when I fly—again, compulsive—but when I plugged the Surface Pro adapter into that, or directly into a wall socket, the white light wouldn’t come on. It wasn’t working. Furthermore, the USB charging port on the power brick wasn’t working either. After verifying that everything else I had could charge just fine, and checking multiple wall sockets, the conclusion was clear: Somehow, unexpectedly, Surface Pro’s power supply has stopped working.

But I’m compulsive, remember? So while I had carried on Surface Pro’s 48 watt power supply, I had also packed Surface RT’s 24 watt power supply. That works fine, so I’m able to keep working on Surface Pro and get it charged, albeit it more slowly than would be the case with its own power supply.

I’m not sure what happened to the Surface Pro power supply, and for some reason I vaguely expect it to work fine when we get home next week. I’ll try it here from time to time too, of course.

So oddly enough, I would have been in serious trouble if I hadn’t brought the extra stuff. That doesn’t excuse the compulsive completely. But it is sort of a strange coincidence.

Discuss this Article 27

StevePerry
on Feb 15, 2013

I have had the problem you describe with your phone, many time when flying both with my wphone 7 and 8. I can't figure it out. I've even had the problem where the phone was fully charged when the plane took off, I don't turn it on until I land, and at that point the phone battery is very close to being dead.

studio4llc
on Feb 15, 2013

Well thanks for the info about swapping out the power supply. My son dropped his new Pro off for me to install a few utilities and set up an external 2tb portable hdd. He neglected to bring the power supply. Now I can use the power supply from my wife's RT. Lifesaver, thanks again for the timely article.

Yeoné
on Feb 15, 2013

Based on pop filter experience, electronics was a poor choice :-).
Enjoy your family and vacation!!!
p.s. Keep up the great work.

markuslaff
on Feb 15, 2013

So basically the Surface RT saved your trip! ;)

are you second guessing your initial review of the RT?

multiplatform
on Feb 15, 2013

Regarding your phone, I notice that Skype for WP8 will suck your battery right down even if the live tile is turned off and you aren't using it. After searching, I found that several people had written Skype support with the same issue. Once you open the app, it starts sucking away. I uninstalled Skype and the problem went away. It is possible that they've fixed it in the last month and I will reinstall if they do. I'm not sure what happened to your phone, but it is worth checking.

Wicc999
on Feb 15, 2013

Damn you, Paul. @ Cancun with a Surface Pro in your hands. I officially envy you.

e942c9
on Feb 15, 2013

Paul,

It is entirely possible that your pro adapter is working by design. I don't know what tolerances engineers have given it, but Mexico power supply is set & rated for 127 Volts @ 60HZ, with a legal tolerance of 10% (meaning it could reach a voltage of 140 VAC). The U.S. and Canada are 120 volts (tolerances set between 114-126V).

The Wattage difference between the two(according to Ohms Law) may account for the difference in operation. The 24 watt power supply offers twice the resistance than the 48 watt. This extra resistance may be enough to make it more adaptable to higher voltage situations.

You may even notice the power supply running hotter than normal when charging (even though you ARE in Mexico).

These things do matter since all that A/C goodness is being converted to D/C by that little brick.

Im not an electrician, but I have a very limited knowledge of electricity.

Hope this helps.
Grant

pthurrott
on Feb 16, 2013

thanks... I have a less educated version of this in the back of my head, which is why I'm wondering if it will just work when I get home.

roncerr
on Feb 16, 2013

"The 24 watt power supply offers twice the resistance than the 48 watt. " While it's true that the 24 watt supply delivers half the current to the load than a 48 watt supply, it doesn't do it with resistance as that would waste half the energy in the form of heat. All we can say for sure is that if this is a comon problem, people should use the 24 watt supply for traveling to places where the available power is out-of-spec. (I wonder what ever happened to the practice of just using 120-240 volt power bricks that adapt to the available voltage.)

Ted T.
on Feb 17, 2013

According to your theory, all Surface devices will become large paperweights when you travel to 220V Europe. I find that very difficult to believe -- that would be a blunder of colossal proportions.

A dead power supply is more likely. But Paul (or any other Surface user) can resolve that quickly -- just look at the brick, it should say something like 100V ~ 240V; 50Hz ~ 60Hz.

Please let us know!

pthurrott
on Feb 17, 2013

Right, sorry. It is of course 100-240V.

Big Swifty
on Feb 16, 2013

I had the same problem with an RT power supply, it died after 4 days. The replacement provided by the Microsoft Store has worked without a problem since the second week of November. I'm typing this on a 128gig Surface Pro which I really like. Let us know what happens with yours!

davidm
on Feb 16, 2013

i doubt your power adapter will work again when you get back home. Just checked my surface pro power adapter

100V-240V, 50/60Hz, meaning this thing should work pretty much anywhere in the world.

sounds like you got a dud. power supplies die randomly,even new ones. bad caps,bridge rectifier,transformer,voltage regulator. too many components that can fail.

Ted T.
on Feb 17, 2013

Should have read all the comments before posting --- glad to have it confirmed that the Surface power supply will indeed work worldwide.

But so Paul's power supply was working for a few days in Boston and then stopped on the trip -- or is it a DOA spare?

webenabler
on Feb 16, 2013

My Surface Pro adapter just went out on me this morning.

I may make a trip in to see if they have a replacement.

Also, as a developer, I did about 6 months with the Samsung Series 7 tablet as my primary - replacing my 17" dev rig. I then went back to a 17" Lenovo W530 and it was such a relief.

I'm waiting for the rest of the world to realize that 10" or even 11" screens are not good for productivity. But I still hold out hope for the docking stations. No way I'd use the type keyboard for productivity either. It's perfect when I have to go portable.

However, I love my Surface RT and Pro - surprisingly the former more...really surprising. The Pro currently has my attention with Bluestacks although 100% DPP kinda sucks.

Always tradeoffs with Mr. Softy...but then there's always choice as well.

milomilo
on Feb 16, 2013

the issue with WP8 device also happened to my Lumia 720 a few times.. the device froze and when reebooted the battery life almost empty. in rare occasion the plugged in phone sometimes dont charge, leaving me with almost dead phone in the morning.

dalestrauss
on Feb 16, 2013

I'll be curious how much slower the RT adapter charges the Pro battery. It sure is more compact and looks easier to carry in a travel bag.

Awake
on Feb 17, 2013

On the phone issue. If you left it on during the flight, it may have spent its battery looking for a cellular signal. AFAIK, phones transmit at a higher power while trying to locate a signal, and doing this over and over (over the Gulf of Mexico) kills the battery. Add trying to lock on to GPS for some background process and you are done.
As for the power brick, they are fragile devices working at the edge of their capabilities to keep the size small. It failed the initial burn-in period. Devices like this tend to fail early or last a long time.

drnoelG
on Feb 17, 2013

Your power supply died. Mine did too just yesterday :(
The RT one works fine though and since I use my Surface mostly plugged in I don't have much of a problem... yet.

Mortarm
on Feb 18, 2013

> I always bring a travel-sized power trip with me when I fly

"I said, I wanna fly the plane!"

scott.girard
on Feb 18, 2013

If you watched "a few" movies while in the air, did you write and watch movies at the same time? How was the multitasking experience? Was this better than the one-app-at-at-time methods other tablets use?

ScubaDog2008
on Feb 18, 2013

Well, Paul, if you'd had a Lumia 920 the flash requirement wouldn't have been an issue at all. I take excellent photos all the way around with this thing--until the full Pureview Lumia comes out, I have yet to find a camera on a phone to match it. Anyway, I've been hearing rumors growing about the build quality of the entire Surface line, which is concerning since I was really hoping the Pro would be my next device. As it is, I think I'm holding out for a Haswell-based tablet. I'm not even considering anything with RT on it--my first tablet MUST be able to replace my notebook in functionality, simple as that. The Surface Pro is, theoretically, ideal for me, but maybe if a "Pro 2" comes out with quality issues resolved and better battery life.....we'll see.

Osborn4
on Feb 18, 2013

So what does a "travel-sized power trip" look like? Does it demand its way only 65% of the time vs. the 100% of a full sized power trip?

arrow22
on Feb 19, 2013

Had my RT power supply die too. The guy at the Microsoft store said they had had a few more with the same problem come back. I suspect a QA issue is at fault here.

SvenJ
on Feb 19, 2013

I'm kind of anal myself. I don't think I own a single piece of portable electronics I don't have, and carry, a backup charge option for. I have two chargers for my RT, and my second one for the Pro comes in today. One carry on, one packed. Nice to know the RT one can charge the Pro, in a pinch. Not recommended by MS if you look at the store descriptions. Other way is supported. I just got my Pebble watch this weekend, and it is making me anxious. Doesn't seem to be a way to order a spare proprietary charge cable yet. Bothers me. ;)

pthurrott
on Feb 19, 2013

Yeah, I've never once considered bringing an extra power supply with me.

SvenJ
on Feb 19, 2013

I wanted to point out to folks, not only did the Pro do decent as far as battery life, it charged a cell phone besides.

Oops, realized he charged using the RT, after I hit post. Would have just deleted the post, but the system only lets you edit. My bad.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use