Going Pro: When Push Comes to Shove

Looks like Surface Pro will get a backup for my first trip with the device

Another detour from our regularly scheduled programming.

We’re flying to Mexico tomorrow morning, marking my first real trip with Surface Pro. But on the eve of this trip, I’m starting to hedge my bets. And I’m not sure if Microsoft’s new tablet is going to make the cut as my only PC for this trip.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m bringing Surface Pro with me, and I’ll try to use it as much as possible. But I’m probably going to have to bring my usual portable—a large 15-inch Ultrabook—as well, just in case. What I’m worried about is that the Surface Pro’s cramped environment—a tiny 10.6-inch screen and the correspondingly small Type Cover keyboard—will simply prove too limiting.

Part of the reason this hasn’t been an issue so far is that I’ve been using Surface Pro at home with a USB-based docking station. This means I’m using the large, 27-inch screen, ergonomic Microsoft keyboard, and large Microsoft mouse that were previously attached to my desktop computer. Aside from a few small issues, using Surface Pro like has been no different from using that desktop PC.

I’ve tried to emulate the to-go experience by using Surface Pro around the house, and of course I’ve brought the device into Boston three times now for meetings, and used it with OneNote to take notes and with Microsoft Word to write articles. It works OK in these scenarios, but there are two issues, one of which is perhaps a bit unique to me.

The main issue, which I’ve documented previously, is the desktop scaling limitations that have been present in Windows for years. I’ve spent way too much time on this, and what I’ve settled on is entirely unacceptable: I use 100 percent screen scaling when tethered the USB dock and desktop display and 150 percent scaling when just using the Surface Pro. This means that I’m continually resizing and repositioning windows, and while it’s not quite maddening it would be if I did it more frequently.

The second issue is that I’m basically too big, and perhaps too old, to use Surface Pro effectively as a standalone portable computer. This screen is simply too small for me, no matter the screen scaling. There’s a reason my main portable PC has a 15-inch screen, and I just prefer the voluminous real estate such a screen affords. Related to this, however, is the keyboard: While I’ve never considered the Samsung Ultrabook’s keyboard to be anything other than average, it’s a much better experience for me, with my large hands, than is the Surface Pro’s Type Cover. I’m not going to give myself carpal tunnel to make a point.

That said, I’m going to try to use Surface Pro when possible. But should I require any lengthy typing sessions, I’m probably going to have to turn to the Ultrabook. This casts doubts on my long-term goals here, of course, but I still think this trip will provide some valuable experience with using Surface Pro in real world travel conditions, not to mention some more casual computing environments. I’ll try not to get sand on it.

And to be clear, many, many people will not have these issues. Most are smaller than me, and most don’t need to type as frequently as I do. 

Discuss this Article 15

sachiwilson
on Feb 14, 2013

I love Mexico. Where will you be going?

As for using the Pro, how do you think it would work if you brought the tablet with an aftermarket keyboard? The iPad has quite a few keyboards that are larger than the width of the device, so I would imagine something similar could be a good complement to the Surface.

BxPete
on Feb 14, 2013

Microsoft makes an excellent Bluetooth Mobile Keyboard 5000 and Bluetooth netbook mouse 5000 that will work quite nicely with the Surface. The keyboard is approximately two inches wider than the Surface and is an ergonomically designed keyboard that is comfortable to use for long periods. BTW, I replaced the totally worthless keyboard and mouse that were shipped with the latest iMac with the Microsoft devices. I am a touch typist that found that not so ergonomic Apple keyboard to be unusable and I got hand cramps after using the Apple mouse for an hour. I unfortunately had to purchase an iMac in order to convert my Windows 8 metro App to an iPad.

multiplatform
on Feb 15, 2013

Give in to reading glasses. They are your friend.

ad24
on Feb 15, 2013

It is time to replace my $400 11.6 notebook, but RT can not replace it because it is x86 incompatible. Pro is too expensive for power I do not need in a mobile device, but not powerful enough to replace by desktop with i7 processor and 16 GB memory.

I still can't believe MS did not make an Atom-based Surface. Luckily for the Win platform, other vendors jumped in with products like Vivotab Smart.

Mustang17
on Feb 15, 2013

I know about your reservations about the size of the keyboard, having shovel sized mitts myself, why can't I have a man sized keyboard? On the same theme I find it difficult to find a big enough mouse. That aside I think the amount of intergration with services like Skydrive etc, it would make life living on the edge that much easier. I've used a silly netbook tethered to my phone in a field in the middle of Shropshire, so I think you will cope down Mexico way.

Scotsman
on Feb 15, 2013

Seems you are getting closer to concluding that the Pro is untenable as a stand-alone device. I suspect many will agree, and that the solution will be for MS to fold more features into a robust RT and do away with the crutch of a full Windows install.

I still hope your home scenario - a Surface Pro and a 1080 monitor - will work for me. If I could find a Pro in stock it would be easier to make a decision...

neonspark
on Feb 15, 2013

I off course could never call anything that is 15 inches portable making surface just about the maximum acceptable and the surge in tablets with the decline of the big hunk laptops points that most people feel we're past the point where we had to haul a server rack with a screen on a trip.

ScubaDog2008
on Feb 15, 2013

So, how do these issues differ from an iPad? It seems to me the very same complaints you're expressing would be true--likely MOREso--on an iPad. I think the idea here is that the Surface Pro would be a better replacement for the iPad without leaving you completely helpless if you discovered you really DID need the capabilities of the notebook you might have chosen to leave at home. Personally, I have no problem whipping out my reading glasses (which I often do anyway) rather than jack with scaling. In fact, I NEVER change scaling. So far, the only drawback I'm concerned with on the Surface Pro is battery. I currently tether my notebook to my Lumia 920, so there'd be no real change in my process there. And it appears that all other aspects of the Surface Pro can easily replace my notebook. But, I ultimately think that the Surface Pro should be considered a powerful tablet with notebook capabilities as a secondary role, not primary.

dalestrauss
on Feb 15, 2013

I agree with BxPete. In fact, while using the Samsung Series 7 Slate I had two sets of the Keyboard 6000/Mouse 5000 at the office and at home - no need to "re-adjust" with different setups. In fact, the Keyboard 6000 comes with a separate numeric keypad if you need one, and is a very comfortable keyboard in its own right. I have found the Wedg(ie) keyboard and mouse to be too small, and the mouse vectors badly with the Surface sending the cursor scooting across the screen - much like the touchpad effect on many ultrabooks.

As for the screen - there is no hope there other than scaling AND increasing the view magnification of the specific software. I guaranty I have worse eyesight than you, and I guess I've just made up my mind to "tough it out" between real 27" monitors. I've seen the Series 9 15" screen, and for me it blows away the MacBook retina despite lower resolution. No tablet of any kind will ever give that effect, and I'm betting you will end up going back to it and a 7"+/- factor convenience tablet - if lucky, maybe a Surface 7 down the road.

jimbie882
on Feb 15, 2013

As usual, you continue to be the human guinea pig. You give another reason why the Surface Pro isn't appropriate for many people. The screen size of 10.6 inches isn't ideal for doing work, but it is a portable PC. I would think it is large enough to at least write some reports; however, you brought a second larger unit. What's up with that? I used to own a 17 inch HP Laptop, but it died on me. Even 17 inches isn't big enough to do work. At work, I use a 19 inch monitor. What I'm trying to say is the 15 inch laptop that you brought isn't significantly larger than the 10.6 inch Surface Pro so why would you bother.

When you travel, you compromise. My feeling is you barely even tried to use the Surface Pro as a stand alone unit when the benefit of its form factor is portability and tablet features. Perhaps this is why it fails. Microsoft didn't present enough apps and features that allows the user to take advantage of the form.

bacbrakr
on Feb 15, 2013

I have to agree with BxPete. Opt not to purchase a type/touch cover for my Surface and use the Bluetooth Mobile Keyboard 5000 and Bluetooth Presentation Mouse 8000 with it. They are both small and light enough to go in my bag and not weigh me down and yet large enough to be usable. This combo means that I have downsize my bag so I am ultra-mobile. Bonus is that they are both Bluetooth, so no pesky dongles (especially with on USB) and not wires to keep you tethered.

strattao
on Feb 15, 2013

So, I am 6'3" (not a small guy myself) and just got back from a week-long business trip to San Diego (I live on the East Coast) using my Surface Pro as my only PC.

I couldn't have been happier with the experience.

I travel regularly for my job and for me the Surface Pro is absolutely perfect. I came from a behemoth of a 15 inch laptop (HP EliteBook 8540w running at 1920 x 1080) and have wanted an ultrabook for years, but there was no way I was going to give up my high resolution.
I don't hook up my Surface Pro to an external monitor, so I can't comment on the scaling issues, but as my laptop replacement I couldn't be happier. I wouldn't dream of carrying my 15" EliteBook on a plane again, and I hope that you don't give in to bringing an additional laptop with you.

I'm not to the point in life where I need reading glasses just yet, but I was VERY nervous about how I would be able to work using a high resolution on such a small screen.
I didn't even skip a beat.
I love how light my carry-on bag is, love the Type keyboard, love that it has all my apps I need. Anyhow, I was able to be 100% productive without a hitch.
Go for it! Flying on an airplane is where Surface Pro shines, especially if you have a power port to plug into, and you certainly don't want to lug around the weight of an extra laptop with you.

JimmyFal
on Feb 15, 2013

You sound like the guy this thing was made for. I much more enjoy hearing comments like yours then the cheerleading sections of the blogosphere.

SvenJ
on Feb 15, 2013

An add-on keyboard/mouse may sound like a good idea, but having to add too many peripherals starts to defeat the purpose of a lightweight portable device. Once you add the keyboard, mouse, extarnal touchpad that supports gestures, USB drive for space, maybe an accessorie battery when those show up, you might just as well be lugging (relatively) a 13-15" ultrabook.

Don't get me wrong, I have a Surface Pro and an RT, and love them. Screen is a bit small as Paul mentions, but bigger comes with baggage I was avoiding. Just saying that if you need the extras to make the device usable for you, maybe it isn't the right device.

You do get the benefit, if travelling, to throw the junk in the checked luggage, and just carry on the Surface, if, of course, you can tolerate possibly not having it when you get where you are going. Redirects, loss, theft does happen.

sharpsone
on Feb 18, 2013

Paul, take a break and enjoy Mexico. Surface Pro should be all you need if you're truly there to vacation! :)

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use