Winning? Dell Replaces Blackberries with Windows Phones

Dell this week said that it has replaced over 15,000 Blackberry handsets in the company with Windows Phone devices. That should be a major win for Microsoft's struggling smart phone platform, but there's just one problem: Dell is using its own previous generation Windows Phone devices as it has thus far declined to release new versions based on Windows Phone 7.5.

Dell global CIO Robin Johnson told The Australian that while the company used to be "a major Blackberry shop," it has now replaced about 50 percent of its Blackberry devices with Windows Phones.

Using your own product seems to make sense. But after releasing the unique Dell Venue Pro last year--it's one of the few Windows Phone handsets to offer a portrait-mode, pull-out hardware keyboard--Dell has never updated or replaced the device. And since then, a whole new generation of Windows Phone handsets have emerged. Just not from Dell.

Dell CFO Brian Gladden first spoke of the plan in a Wall Street Journal interview last year. However, he said at the time that Dell would replace all of its then-25,000 Blackberries and the company had been working on the scheme for "several months." A year and a half later, roughly speaking, some 10,000 Dell employees are apparently clinging to their RIM devices.

RIM at the time called the Dell plan "a publicity stunt". "We find it highly unlikely that they will actually save any money with this move and far more likely they were looking for a little free publicity," RIM senior vice president of corporate marketing Mark Guibert said a year ago. "Consider all the hard and soft costs of purchasing, deploying and supporting new devices and new software inside a company."

More important, where the heck are Dell's second-generation Windows Phone handsets?

Discuss this Article 6

cditty
on Nov 19, 2011
More than likely, they are doing this with unsold stock. I do think that the company version is probably updated to Mango, though. I would not be surprised at all if Microsoft helped them create an update and even put in some special enterprise features a little early for them. That was a nice phone.
beaups
on Nov 19, 2011
^Only problem is DVP compass doesn't work with Mango. So...all those employees lost compatibility with every app that relies on it. Think AR, Navigation, etc.
quantumforce1
on Nov 19, 2011
As an owner of a DVP: I have no ambition to ever have another Dell product; especially a phone made by Dell. 1. Took 3-4 weeks longer to receive the phone than it was to be out originally. Poor communication from Dell during this wait! 2. The first 7 or 8 months, the phone was almost a brick. Badly needed a FW update, of which, when they [Dell] finally got around to updating - made the phone FINALLY work (8 months or so after a delayed delivery). 3. During those months of waiting - Dell would not even acknowledge that there were problems with the phone for the longest time (May if memory serves me well), then it took another 3 months or so for the update to finally be released. HORRIBLE! 4. Since Mango - The compass does not work and of course Dell has not responded or given us any status updates. 5. I LOVE the Microsoft Windows Phone software and will be buying another phone (tomorrow actually - HTC Titan). Never Dell, no way, no how - they don't have a big enough budget to buy me again!!! Bottom line: Dell is HORRIBLE about admitting their mistakes and shorcomings on this device. They have been HORRIBLE about communicating what their intent(s) are to handle us - the paying users - of a device that was almost a brick for the first 8 months of ownership and STILL does not have full functionality (11.5 months since release). The Last Bottom Line: We had a similar issues concerning Dell's server line 2005/6 - I had to pull the plug on them then too. We moved to all HP servers, etc.. There's a reason Dell has fallen from grace! QF
quantumforce1
on Nov 19, 2011
As an owner of a DVP: I have no ambition to ever have another Dell product; especially a phone made by Dell. 1. Took 3-4 weeks longer to receive the phone than it was to be out originally. Poor communication from Dell during this wait! 2. The first 7 or 8 months, the phone was almost a brick. Badly needed a FW update, of which, when they [Dell] finally got around to updating - made the phone FINALLY work (8 months or so after a delayed delivery). 3. During those months of waiting - Dell would not even acknowledge that there were problems with the phone for the longest time (May if memory serves me well), then it took another 3 months or so for the update to finally be released. HORRIBLE! 4. Since Mango - The compass does not work and of course Dell has not responded or given us any status updates. 5. I LOVE the Microsoft Windows Phone software and will be buying another phone (tomorrow actually - HTC Titan). Never Dell, no way, no how - they don't have a big enough budget to buy me again!!! Bottom line: Dell is HORRIBLE about admitting their mistakes and shorcomings on this device. They have been HORRIBLE about communicating what their intent(s) are to handle us - the paying users - of a device that was almost a brick for the first 8 months of ownership and STILL does not have full functionality (11.5 months since release). The Last Bottom Line: We had a similar issues concerning Dell's server line 2005/6 - I had to pull the plug on them then too. We moved to all HP servers, etc.. There's a reason Dell has fallen from grace! QF
MikeSharpe
on Nov 19, 2011
Just to be clear, the Venue Pro has been updated to Mango. Mine is unlocked (as it isn't sold here in Australia so I imported one from the US) and I updated it the day Mango started rolling out. There aren't any (new or old) WP7/7.5 devices I'd buy ahead of a VP yet - the WP soft keyboard is great, but I still revert to hardware when I'm typing more than a very short message. Seems like a suitable formfactor to replace a Blackberry, too? FWIW navigation works OK without a compass on my Venue Pro, though augmented reality wouldn't.
Cleveland72
on Nov 20, 2011
hey guys, this website is actually getting crazy! sending free ipad to one every 10 new subscriber!! check it out here http://bit.ly/s3fBG2

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use