Why Surface RT? [Infographic]

Microsoft Surface with Windows RT has several key advantages over the Apple iPad

Late last year, I wrote a series of articles called “Why Windows RT?” in which I highlighted several ways in which Microsoft’s Surface with Windows RT beat the Apple iPad. Here’s a nice summary of the series in attractive infographic form. 

why Surface RT infographic

Why Windows Surface RT? - An infographic by the team at Paul Thurrott's SuperSite for Windows

Embed "Why Windows Surface RT?" on Your Site: Copy and Paste the Code Below

 

Here are the original articles:

Part 1: Multiple Users

Part 2: Microsoft Office

Part 3: USB

Part 4: Task Switching

Part 5: Mouse

Part 6: Windows RT

Discuss this Article 17

pmbAustin
on Jan 7, 2013

Being able to see Windows networks and having a desktop environment is also pretty huge. It's so easy to just fire up file manager and drag and drop documents from my desktop shares. And the integration with Skydrive and the SkyDrive app are just better than anything I experienced with iCloud. And the XBox/Xbox-Live integration is cool too.

Of course, the down-sides are pretty significant too: the number, depth, and quality of apps in the ecosystem is a big one. The weakness of the mail app is another. The fact that some common settings (like when the display dims/turns-off) are buried in the desktop control panel... difficult to find for some people not all that familiar with Windows Desktop.

For me the trade-off is worth it. I love the size, feel, and power of the device, and how it "just works" so well with my Windows 8 desktop and home network. Though I do wish it could be a legitimate full HomeGroup member. Not sure why there is that limitation, but I've worked around it for the most part.

michaelljones
on Jan 7, 2013

Nice graphic, and I enjoy my Surface RT quite a bit. It still has some rough edges and a few too many app crashes, but it has improved remarkably since I got it.

One slight nit pick, while there is no mouse app, there is a limited keyboard app for the 2 Surface keyboards that let you control some of the functionality. Still not as full featured as the PC counterparts, but it's at least there.

saqrkh
on Jan 7, 2013

Microsoft should just make Windows RT free to the OEMs, that is the only way you're going to (1) entice them away from Android, and (2) allow them to price RT units more competitively.

pmbAustin
on Jan 7, 2013

Well, given it includes MS Office 2013 Home & Student, probably not FREE... but significantly lower cost than what is there now.

Alex Alexzander
on Jan 7, 2013

Now you're talking. There is a lot of value there.

nick.karasev
on Jan 7, 2013

This is great. But can I add my few cents in addition to a cool Xbox integration already mentioned?

First is the kickstand and the touch/type covers. Don't underestimate them! These are truly amazing (especially the TypeCover). Nothing in iPad compares in usability and productivity of the resulting solution, especially when you factor in the width and weight. Since I got my Surface, I pretty much stopped using laptop unless I have to write code or work in the environment where a luxury of horizontal surfaces is not available and I have a lot of typing to do -- arguably not a typical environment. Even an airplane features a stowaway table.

Permanent memory expansion via MicroSD and ability to hot-swap cards or mount card memory as directories is huge for seamlessly expanding your tablet's storage capacity without adding any bulk.

And what about a standard micro-HDMI output which lets you connect your Surface to any monitor, projector, or TV? With iPad, you would have to purchase and carry $30 dongle to accomplish the same. What's even better, with Windows RT, all standard output options like mirroring or extending or external monitor only are available, and it is very easy to switch between the two.

Finally, Task Switching should definitely be expanded to mention seamless contract-based sharing via Sharing charm, ability to send data to other devices via Devices charm, be it playing music on your Xbox or printing a document. Also important are application preferences, now found in the same place in all applications similar to OS X making configuration discovery so much easier. Auto-hide app bars save a lot of space while giving you context-sensitive command options. Yes, these are things shared with Windows 8 desktop, but they make your work experience so much better.

Finally comes a very decent 16:9 screen that makes watching movies a way better and natural experience as compared to letter-boxed versions on iPad.

Paul mentioned Tegra 3 sluggish performance and application stability in many of his articles, and I have to concur. Still my experience with Surface RT was comparable to iPad and definitely better than Android tablets. I think the only major gripe today would be the apps. But these are not going to happen overnight, no matter what the rate of adoption is. Here's hoping we are going to see positive changes in this department too in the coming months.

neonspark
on Jan 7, 2013

I say my biggest RT joy has been the USB port. I typically use it to plug in a range of devices, even after market Skype boxes which work perfectly. everybody in the office with an ipad just has to wait for my surface to arrive and do the real work...you know, as it should :)

ingenuity1
on Jan 7, 2013

Apple iOS 5+ has an app switcher. I use it on my iPad all the time. Four finger swipe up -> Pick your app. You can also Four finger swipe left/right to go app-to-app. Amazingly nearly ever app on my iPad is "running" in the background. They never get fully tombstoned.

The single stupidest reason I have to use their app switcher is because if you want to insert more than one picture in your email you have to switch back and fourth between the photos app and the email and click-hold -> copy then click-hold -> paste the things in one at a time.

mjplenty
on Jan 7, 2013

@Ingenuity1. If you are using the built-in Photos app and the built-in Mail app on the iPad, you can start in the Photos app first and then tap Edit > select every picture you want to send > tap share > tap Mail. This will build an email with all of the photos already attached. Other apps with photos, yes, your way would be required.

pthurrott
on Jan 8, 2013

I was hoping this would turn into a support forum for iPad users, thanks. ;) No, not really.

Roos
on Jan 7, 2013

For an "Infographic" its a bit heavy on type, a bit light on the graphic...maybe your just enjoying your touch cover a bit too much :)

jeffsters
on Jan 8, 2013

Some good stuff. But I disagree, of course, with some points.

1. iPad has parental controls, all of those listed, plus restrictions on in-app purchases.
2. Not sure what "better keyboard" support means. Apple's works fine and pretty much any BT keyboard I've thrown at the iPad it handles fine. There are also more 3rd party keyboards specifically made for the iPad than the RT
3. When it comes to printer support you could easily flip that with "iPad comes ready to work with new AirPrint enabled printers requiring no drivers, or future driver issues, unlike Surface RT."
4. No keyboard needed to easily switch between apps with two finger swipe.
5. iWork for iPad is true tablet format productivity designed from the ground up and not with a desktop view.

Anyway...carry on!

Waethorn
on Jan 8, 2013

"iPad comes ready to work with new AirPrint enabled printers requiring no drivers, or future driver issues, unlike Surface RT."

Sorry, but that's just incorrect. The iPad has included drivers in the operating system. Apple has (FINALLY!) started modifying their AirPrint protocol to support more devices that simultaneously support the WSD (Web Services for Devices) protocol, which allows Windows systems (including RT) to automatically discover and install class drivers for full functionality of network-connected printing and multifunction devices More devices support WSD than do AirPrint though, so Windows still has the advantage.

"No keyboard needed to easily switch between apps with two finger swipe"

Only one finger is need to switch between apps on Windows 8/RT

LemonSaucy
on Jan 8, 2013

Windows RT is hmm so so .. one might want it if one wants to make use of the Microsoft walled garden prison of applications over, say, the Apple walled garden prison.

One might be better off with the soon available Surface (x86) tablet running a full version of Windows. It will cost a bit more, but it's not running the the crippleware that Windows RT is; and in the long run the employer of the full Windows device will most likely find many reasons to be much more happy with it on a device that's free.

brians (not verified)
on Jan 8, 2013

You say "only Surface works with a mouse". Definitely not true, Android has worked with a mouse well before Windows 8 shipped.
Oh, Android also supports Alt-Tab to switch tasks from a keyboard.

robertnd2
on Jan 8, 2013

I have ditched my heavy corporate issued core I5 laptop and have been solely using the Surface RT as an experiment. Its been flawless. Run wireless keyboard and mouse with HDMI connection to large external monitor while in the office. I connect to all of corporate applications thru the Citrix APP which is fast and runs everything without a hiccup. Carry device while on the go and love it for casual home use. I agree with the other poster..the kickstand and the touch/type cover integration is really well done. I didn't intend to buy the RT, but I got sick of waiting and said what the hell. I'll probably get the surface pro in a few weeks for a speed boost and the active digitizer. What to do with the RT version then? Ha ha!

Mortarm
on Jan 18, 2013

Nice job, Paul. Did you create it in RT Office?

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use