Why Surface RT? Part 4: Task Switching

A simple way to switch between apps puts Surface over the top

While the iPad has certain ecosystem advantages over the recently-released Surface with Windows RT, Microsoft’s entry does of course edge out the Apple device in some key areas as well. And if you’re actually trying to get work done, the ability to easily task switch on the Surface—using any input method, not just touch—is a huge advantage over the iPad.

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: Apple could seriously close the productivity gap between its iPad and the Surface (and other Windows devices) by adding one crucial missing feature to iOS: Simply allow users to task switch by using the ALT + TAB (or, on Apple keyboards, COMMAND + TAB) keyboard combination. Today, even those iPad users with keyboards need to actually reach up and touch the screen to switch back and forth between apps. That’s just not tedious, it’s counterproductive.

On Surface with Windows RT, as with all Windows devices, you have choice. And if you’re a keyboard user, the previous app is just a simple and well-understood key combination (ALT + TAB) away. So even when you’re using full-screen Metro-style apps, you can quickly move back and forth between two or more them, something that is not possible, or easy, on the iPad.

Task switching isn’t just about ALT + TAB, which is technically called Windows Flip. Windows 8 and RT also offer the Metro-style Switcher interface (WINKEY + TAB), which can be activated by mouse, trackpad gestures, or by multi-touch as well. And you can swipe between running Metro-style apps, a la the iPad, by swiping across the entire screen horizontally.

And make sure you understand the distinction: Yeah, it works with a mouse too. Or a stylus. Or a trackpad, with multi-touch gestures. Your choice.

And Surface (and Windows RT and 8 in general) offers another nicety that’s not available on the iPad: Side-by-side apps. Using the new Snap feature, you can place any two Metro-style apps (or a Metro-style app and the desktop) side-by-side on the screen together, where one app is the primary app and the other is said to be snapped to the side.

While this view is not perfect for all situations, it does offer a key productivity-related advantage over the iPad too, cementing the iPad’s role as a purely consumption device.

Discuss this Article 7

kevm14
on Nov 12, 2012

Don't forget about having desktop windows snapped to the side to give you 50/50 (like IE10 and MS Word).

sachiwilson
on Nov 12, 2012

Can you open a full page of Word document side-by-side with another app? I don't care about the blank margins, but is it possible to set it up so that you can easily see all the text on a typical page? (My guess is that it is barely wide enough but that the height of the screen would not be enough to show a full page).

egsigma
on Nov 14, 2012

That depends on too many variables, like how big you want it to be. You can fit a whole page on a postcard if you shrink it enough, lol

Earlkarp
on Nov 12, 2012

I recently was able to try out the Surface and learned of the various means to "swipe" across the screen be it to close an app swiping top to bottom, bring in the start menu from the right, or swiping in from the left to task switch (Windows Flip). With any of these motions it helps to start them with your finger off of the edge of the screen. With these new found abilities I tried them out on my year old touch sensitive screen all in one which I had upgraded to Windows 8 Pro, however, I discovered an issue on my device with all of these methods for swiping. The touch screen does not have edge to edge glass and instead has a plastic frame that surrounds the screen. This frame creates a ridge which protudes out from the screen about a 1/8 of an inch around the edge making it difficult to wedge your finger into the edge deep enough to initiate any of these swipes. Instead these motions are interpreted as attempts to scroll the current active window. Maybe someone with needle-nose-fingers would not have this issue. So, when looking at touch sensitive monitors/screens this is something to watch out for. Perhaps MS made this as part of their requirments for Windows 8 compatibility and this will not be experienced on brand new equipment.?

tboggs13
on Nov 12, 2012

Correct, new devices typically use capacitive screens which should be flush across the entire surface of the display like a smartphone or surface.

The older displays, like you describe are optical. That thick border you mention is a series of emitters and receivers that create an invisible light field across the surface of the display. When you touch the screen, you are breaking the beams of light.

In order to trigger the edge menus on Windows 8, you have to swipe across the first pixel of the display. Since your finger is rather round, this is difficult. I found that a stylus with a fairly sharp point helped quite a bit when I was testing the developer preview.

Another problem is the due to the nature of optical sensors, they can only track two point of contact. And that usually fails if you try to rotate something on screen.

IanYates82
on Nov 13, 2012

My Motion J3500 is like this - two points of contact. The edges of the screen don't have too much of a ridge though and, as said, if you start with your finger off the edge of the screen it's easy. My 5 year old gets it and the 3 year old is just about there :)

I think there was a "Building Windows 8" blog post about this topic....

Yep - here it is - http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2012/03/28/touch-hardware-and-windows...

Worth a read!

Bruno H
on Nov 14, 2012

WINKEY + TAB ?

I Believe that combination only works on older Windows versions. WINKEY + TAB was one of my favorites on Windows 7 but it does nothing on my Windows 8 machine.

Ah, well, ALT + TAB works fine...

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use