Xbox Music Feature Focus: Album Match

It's not the scan-and-match service we all want, but it's a start

Supported on: Windows 8, Windows RT
Requires Xbox LIVE Gold subscription: No
Requires Xbox Music Pass subscription: No

While a scan-and-match feature will be added to Xbox Music in the coming year, the Xbox Music app for Windows 8 already includes a feature that lets you manually add music from your PC to your personal Xbox Music cloud collection. This feature, which I call album match, makes matched music available for streaming or downloading on your other Windows 8 devices and Windows Phone 8 handsets.

Note: Windows 8 includes Windows 8, Windows 8 Pro, and Windows RT.

Note: While album matching is only available in Windows 8, the music you match is placed in your Xbox Music cloud collection, which is also available in Windows Phone 8. I will write about cloud collection in a future feature focus article.

Note: As a number of readers have already noted, an automated scan-and-match feature is sort of available now in the Xbox Music app in Windows 8. In my experience this service is almost randomly available and is most likely not complete or even broadly available in different markets. My expectation is that it will be improved and officially announced in the coming year as Microsoft previously promised. Regardless, that is a separate feature than album match, which is the manual process described here.

Album match is no substitute for a true scan-and-match service, but it does allow you to begin stocking your own Xbox Music cloud collection with some of your own music. In this way, it works somewhat like Amazon Cloud Player, Google Play Music, or Apple iTunes Match in that music matched from your own personal collection is stored in the cloud so you can access it from your devices. And no uploading is required.

Unfortunately, album match doesn’t work very well. Consider the following limitations:

Albums only. Album match can only match albums, and not artists, songs, or playlists.

Manual, not automatic. You can only match one album at a time, so it is tedious to use with large collections.

Content must be in Microsoft’s online collection. It will only work with music that Microsoft has in its Xbox Music Store collection, and then only with that music which is licensed for streaming. (And no, there’s no way to find out which content is licensed appropriately.)

It often just doesn’t work. The worst aspect of album match is that it often doesn’t work at all. So even though you appear to have successful matched an album, that album is never added to your personal Xbox Music cloud collection. No error is given, no explanation provided.

While these limitations may seem daunting, album match actually works pretty well for small collections, especially when the music is normal, readily-available content from major acts. I’ve used it to store many albums in Xbox Music, which—for now at least—doesn’t appear to have any storage or song count limitations. This functionality is freely available.

(Note: That could change. Perhaps the cloud collection and scan-and-match feature will eventually require at least an Xbox LIVE Gold subscription. There’s also the question of storage allotment, and whether Microsoft will simply provide what it essentially unlimited music storage going forward. For now, there does not appear to be any limitation.)

To match an album to Xbox Music, right-click an album (or, with a touch-based system, select by swiping to the right). When you do, a selection mark appears next to the album and the app bar appears.

Select Match album info from the app bar. (Note that in some cases, this command will be available via the More button.) When you do, a wizard appears, helping you choose the album in Xbox Music that matches the one you selected.

In some cases, this is straightforward and the choice is obvious. Other times, you will need to choose the album from a list or tap the “Don’t see the right album?” link to search for the correct entry.

When you do select an album that matches the one you previously selected, the wizard will list the songs in the album with a checkmark next to each song that was successfully matched. If you’re lucky—or have at least selected to match a very common album—all songs will be matched and you can simply click Finish to complete the process.

In other cases, however, all of songs can’t be matched, so you will only see checkmarks next to some songs. When this happens, you will go through a fairly tedious song-by-song matching process where you match each song, in turn, to the appropriate song on the Xbox Music-hosted album.

After matching each song—or at least some of them, because in some cases I’ve seen, you can’t actually match all of them—click Finish and you’re done.

In still other cases, of course, you won’t be able to match an album because it isn’t available in Xbox Music or doesn’t have streaming rights.

When you do match an album, you’ll see a temporary icon appear next to the album in Xbox Music, indicating that the album is being matched.

Then, the icon will change to a cloud icon, indicating that it is matched and available on your current PC for offline use.

When you run Xbox Music on another PC or device, you’ll see a different icon indicating that the album is available for streaming from the cloud. Or you can select it and choose Download from the app bar to make it available for offline playback as well. It is your music, after all.

Matched albums are also available in Windows Phone 8 for both streaming and downloading if you have an Xbox Music Pass subscription. (The option “Xbox Music cloud collection” must be enabled in Settings for this content to appear in Music + Videos, however.) You’ll see the same streaming icon next to each song name, indicating that the music is in your personal cloud collection and can be streamed or downloaded for offline use.

To download a song, just tap and hold on the song and choose Download from the menu that appears. Or, use the Select app bar button to select two or more of the songs in an album and download them all at once using the Download app bar button that appears.

Discuss this Article 29

pmbAustin
on Dec 29, 2012

When I first synched my WP8 phone with the "Windows Phone 8" app on Windows 8, it automatically matched MOST of my collection. For some reason, some albums (available in the Xbox Music store, available for MP3 purchase) didn't sync. But it did scan my entire collection, and did a fair job of putting most of it in the cloud. Just FYI.

ArchieCoder
on Dec 29, 2012

Hi Paul,

I don't understand your point: "Manual, not automatic. You can only match one album at a time, so it is tedious to use with large collections."

This week, I discovered the Xbox Music Cloud setting and after it turned on, I could see all my albums in my Windows Phone 8.

Note: I have a Xbox Music Pass and I don't have a Xbox Gold subscription.

pthurrott
on Dec 29, 2012

That's a different feature. Album match as I've described it is where you can do this manually.

I believe that the feature you're referring to is not complete and is the scan-and-match service that will eventually be improved and just work. (And be officially announced.)

PerryReed
on Dec 29, 2012

The biggest problem I've had with Xbox Music so far is that about half of the music I previously downloaded with the Zune app simply will not play in the Xbox app at all. It's very odd and incredibly annoying. I've all found that some albums I downloaded from Zune will not match at all in Xbox. It's bewildering.

grking
on Dec 29, 2012

I am a little confused, as it was automatic for me. One morning I opened the music app on my surface, and about half my 20k song collection was available. Over the next few days about another 25% was added, and the rest were never matched. For the most part, it was ok, but iTunes had done a better job at matching.

TalTarablus
on Dec 29, 2012

Ive noticed a disturbing fact about Xbox Music:
All the music I download as part of the Xbox Music Pass is 192kbps, unlike the 256kbps advertised and much lower than the modern 320kbps.
When I asked a micro soft representative about this, they replied that the quality of the music is determined by the artists and in what quality they decide to put in the Xbox Music Collection.
So Microsoft isn't streamlining the quality standard, plus not providing us with the promised 256kbps, which because its not them, they can't do anything about it.

rth314
on Dec 31, 2012

When you download you get DRMed WMA files. According to Microsoft WMA has better sound quality than MP3 at the same bitrate. So theoretically, a 192kbps WMA file may sound similar to a 256kbps MP3.

arnehelseth
on Dec 29, 2012

What I'm still unclear on is this; does the scan and match or cloud collection require a Xbox Music Pass subscription? I asked xboxsupport about this and was told it did, but this makes no sense to me as it provides no value add on top of the streaming already available with a subscription?!

I currently have a Pass so can't tell for sure, but I do know my matched albums did not show up on my WP8 until the I purchased the pass.

Jccoyle
on Dec 29, 2012

I don't have a music pass and I don't see my albums I matched on my Nokia 920. That's still the mystery to me..will this match feature cost for use on a Windows Phone 8 ?
a) you need Xbox Music Pass b) you need Xbox Live Gold or c) you need both ????

can anyone confirm any of the above ?

pthurrott
on Dec 29, 2012

Xbox Music Pass is not required for use on Windows 8/RT devices.

Xbox Music Pass *is* required to access matched music on Windows Phone 8. I will change the article to address that, sorry for the confusion.

Jccoyle
on Dec 29, 2012

If you need to purchase a Music Pass to have access to your matched albums, that has zero value since those same albums would already be available to stream with the music pass. That just can't be right, but then again, this is Microsoft were talking about, perfector of good communication.

pthurrott
on Dec 29, 2012

Zune Music Pass is NOT required for Windows 8/RT matching. So it has far more than zero value.

rth314
on Dec 31, 2012

The value is being able to select from a curated list of your own music on other devices such as Windows Phone, Surface, or other Windows PCs. It's much easier to find my own music this way, rather than having to search in the Music Store and scroll through albums I'm not interested in.

Jccoyle
on Dec 29, 2012

My point is in regards to matched songs available on a Windows Phone 8. If you needed Music Pass to have the W8/RT songs matched to your phone, those same songs would already be made available through streaming offered with the music pass. I'm struggling trying to figure out why my matched songs do not show on my Nokia 920. Plus with free streaming on the Win 8 and RT right now, why would you need those matched songs there? You can stream them for free at the moment, 10 hours a month later on. Maybe the future will reveal more value ?

pthurrott
on Dec 29, 2012

Answered above. Access to matched music on Windows Phone 8 does require an Xbox Music Pass.

rockycpa
on Dec 29, 2012

My only complaint about the XBOX Music is that it takes soooo long to get a song going, then when one song ends, it takes another long time to get started. I had Spotify for a while and it seemed almost instant.

Crabber50
on Dec 29, 2012

It seems that I cannot play media downloaded via the new Windows 8 Music app in Media Center? I have a Music Pass and Xbox Gold account and consume 90% of my media via Media Center. Zune music pass content still works fine. Is this the way things will stay?

JeffreyH
on Dec 30, 2012

Another problem on Windows Phone 8 is that you get duplicate entries in the Music app. On the one hand, it shows your Music in the cloud (provided that you matched your collection before on Win8/RT). On the other hand, it shows the same music again on your SD Card (I used the "Metro" phone app to sync my Music between PC and Phone). For some reason Windows Phone doesn't seem able to recognize that it is the same music and there is variation albums for example. Only solution the Microsoft online forums provide is switching off the cloud collection option. Too bad, could be a great service

pmbAustin
on Dec 30, 2012

What does it mean when you do the music match for an album, and after the matching (and fixing up random tracks), the icon doesn't change, and the album doesn't appear in the cloud at any point? I've had that happen to dozens of albums as I tried matching the ones that weren't "auto-matched" by the Windows Phone 8 app. It's just like nothing happens. I've even repeated the process to try and kick start it... and for some albums, it's just nothing. No hint as to why.

Also, there seems to be no way to "force" the Windows Phone 8 app to do the matching, that I've found... it did it automatically the first time it fired up, and not since then. I'm not seeing any option to trigger it either. Any info on that?

zikifer
on Jan 1, 2013

Yeah I see that a lot as well. I think if you have to click the "Don't see the right album?" link it doesn't match at all.

pmbAustin
on Jan 3, 2013

...which is odd, because the moment I click the "don't see the right album" link, it usually shows exactly the right album. Which is confusing as to why it didn't show up right away instead of forcing me to click the link to see more.

farbod.ab
on Dec 31, 2012

I just have a question Paul, you said "Matched albums are also available in Windows Phone 8 for both streaming and downloading if you have an Xbox Music Pass subscription.

Just to make sure, does that mean a subscription is required for both streaming and downloading your music from the cloud or just downloading it?

pthurrott
on Dec 31, 2012

If you don't have Xbox Music Pass you won't see matched music on your phone at all. So you can't stream or download it.

bradwyoung
on Dec 31, 2012

I just set up my Nokia 920 and currently the only music available is music from Xbox Music in cloud. However, I don't have a Xbox Music Pass. Also, I have no idea how the music that is showing up got matched, because when I match additional albums, they never show up and the albums that do show up I did not go through match. I have tried several different albums and none of them ever show up on my 920. Now, I do see them on my Surface and my other Windows 8 computer, but I see a lot more than just the ones that I manually match. I think that is because, the 'Xbox Music Cloud' setting is on by default and on my main computer where I have my music collection so it automatically tried to match them. However, it causes a huge mess (multiple copies of same album, albums with partial track lists, etc) and the only way I have found to fix it is to uninstall the app, and reinstall from app store and the immediately go in and disable the setting. I think whatever it automatically 'matched' is still what is showing up on my other Windows 8/RT computers. I really wish there was like a website you could go to and see what is in your Xbox Music Cloud storage and even reset/clear it. Something like a cloud music player like Amazon has. I would also, be happy if I could just upload my music to my Skydrive account and then it would just show up in the Music app on computer and phone and not go to Skydrive app.

pmbAustin
on Jan 1, 2013

So I've noticed what must be some bugs in the Xbox Music app on my laptop (real windows 8). I have all my music locally (thousands of tracks) and an Xbox Music Pass. But some of the albums I have show with the icon that says "Streaming only". Which makes no sense since the track is local. Others show no icon at all (no "cloud"), but when I open the album, every single track has a "cloud" icon next to it... it's all matched, but the album isn't?

Microsoft really needs to clean this stuff up. It's too awkward and confusing right now, and I think needlessly so.

Jccoyle
on Jan 2, 2013

I'm hoping when and if this match feature is fully revealed this year, MS will offer the feature for $25 a year, the same way Apple and Amazon offers. Right now, I don't see why I would want a matched album on my phone if that same album is offered by Xbox Music Pass already to stream. Since the only way to see your matched collection is to pay $9.99 a month.

Match should be a seperate product or choice. I want to stream my collection and would pay for that service. You don't need match if you're paying for Music pass, those songs are already there to stream, it's the same file.

elmortero
on Jan 3, 2013

Has anyone else noticed that local music saved on your surface doesn't display album artwork? I've been very disappointed with Xbox Music. I also get WiFi hangups (Limited) after a short time of using the app.

RobHalligan
on Jan 3, 2013

Just to add to the muddle...I'm in the US and have W7, WP8, and a Music Pass. Some of my music just showed up on my WP8 device without ever syncing the phone to any computer.

bryanj26
on Jan 3, 2013

I'm going to second (or third or whatever number its up to) reports of issues with duplicate copies of things - some of which are only shells with nothing in them. In addition, Paul has it right when he says "normal, readily available content from major acts". I have a lot of music that doesn't fit that description and Xbox Music shredded albums and matched things to artists that didn't have anything to do with the actual artist. Honestly, it was ugly. It feels like XBM almost overwrites metadata rather than filling in gaps but I can't quite be sure. [Also, this is probably more the auto-scan-and-match feature. However, if I stay connected to the XBM data/cloud at all, no matter if I've manually added an album, XBM tries to overwrite it with whatever data it thinks applies. Very, very confusing.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• 120 Technical
Sessions
• Networking with Peers
• Expert Speakers


Come See Paul Thurrott & Mary Jo Foley in Person!

Register Now

Office 365 InfoCenter

Get the latest insight and info from Paul

Read Now!

What I Use